Checkout our most recent Resource Corner!
Envision Education is excited to share the culmination of its two-year research project, Pursuing Equity for Black & Latine Students with Learning Differences, which
documents and illustrates the systems, practices, cultures, and supports that are associated with the well being and success of Black and Latine students with learning differences – students with disabilities and multilingual students with disabilities.
In 2023, Envision Learning Partners (ELP) and Social Policy Research Associates (SPR) embarked on a research study to identify and learn from schools that demonstrated positive outcomes for Black and Latine students with learning differences (including students with disabilities and multilingual learners). After a review of data from secondary schools across the country, the study team identified two schools for a more in-depth study, which was conducted during the 2023–2024 school year.
The results of the research are shared through case studies of the two schools that were the focus of the research: 1) Crosstown High: Building a Culture of Inclusion; 2) Capital City: An Inclusive School Community Committed to Whole-Child Learning and Well Being; and 3) An Executive Summary/Synthesis of Findings.
In addition, we have authored four practice briefs based on the findings of the research that provide practical steps that schools can take to create more inclusive environments that support the success of Black and Latine students with learning differences.
- Co-teaching: A Means to Creating Inclusive and Equitable General Education Classrooms
- UDL: Universal Design for Learning in a Culturally Responsive Context
- Culturally Responsive Practices: An Inclusive, Culturally Responsive School Culture That Fosters Relationships
- Competency-Based Learning and Assessment: Assessment and Grading Practices That Support an Inclusive Learning Culture
This research was made possible through the generous support of New Profit, a venture philanthropic organization, and the Oak Foundation.

Resource Corner: Pursuing Equity for Black and Latine Students with Learning Differences Case Studies & Practice Briefs
During his keynote at last fall’s EdLeader21 Conference, educational thought leader, Tony Wagner, did not mince words. “A graduate portrait without an assessment,” he said, “is useless.”
The audience members—mainly district leaders from around the country—audibly shifted in their seats. Although it’s hard to disagree, it’s also hard to pull off. How can school districts assess skills that are as complex as the ones we see on a typical graduate profile?
Tony followed up his challenge with two recommendations:
- “Every student should have a digital portfolio.”
- “Every student should present or defend their learning.”
He’s right. Portfolio assessment and presentations of learning (which come in many forms, including defenses and student-led conferences) are two effective, customizable, scalable, and actionable ways to move from “poster to practice.”
ELP cheers the graduate profile movement because of its potential to change our society’s conception of education’s purpose. But we also worry for the movement. If we don’t see graduate profiles made visible in the actual work of our students—“show don’t tell,” says this old English teacher—then we’re destined to look back on this as another edu-trend that came to nothing. That’s why Tony Wagner’s admonition is so urgent.
The challenge of assessing graduate profiles is one of the major themes of next month’s Assessment for Learning Conference. I know I will see many of you there, and I am excited for the opportunity to work on this together.

Justin Wells,
ELP Executive Director
This month, Envision Education’s CEO, Gia Truong is our guest blogger, writing about our Portfolio Defense assessment model, it’s impact on students and the work we are doing collectively to improve it. We know that our model is transformative for some, but not yet for all and not consistently for the most marginalized. In order to truly serve our black and brown students, we must find ways to center their experiences and eliminate racist structures within our system, so that all students have access to transformative learning experiences. Read on to learn what we are doing…
Envision Schools’ mission is to transform the lives of students – especially those who will be the first in their families to graduate from college – by preparing them for success in college, career, and life. We accomplish our mission through our Portfolio Defense assessment model, which authentically measures the most important things students need in order to succeed in college and career. Portfolio Defense gives students the academic, social-emotional and leadership skills they need to get into college and persist. One of the biggest problems facing underserved students is educational inequity. Because of this inequity, poor students are far less likely to receive an education that will transform their life trajectory. We know that only 1 out of 10 low-income students earns a 4-year college degree by their mid-twenties, significantly limiting their income potential for their entire lives.
The signature practice of every Envision school is the Portfolio Defense. In 8th, 10th and 12th grades, every Envision student stands before a panel of teachers, peers, family and friends, and delivers a comprehensive presentation that demonstrates how and why they are ready for the next academic challenge. Every defense is both an authentic academic assessment and a celebration of what students have accomplished. The essential outcome of the model, above and beyond rigorous academic preparation, is the agency our students can develop: they graduate ready to take charge of their educational future and advocate for themselves on the path to receiving a college degree.
We also know that our model is not yet building that agency for enough of our students. It is transformative for some, but not yet for all and not consistently for the most marginalized. We know that in order to truly serve our black and brown students, we must find ways to center their experiences and eliminate racist structures within our system, so that all students have access to transformative learning experiences.
Last year, Envision Academy (EA), our Oakland California school’s 11th and 12th grade teachers observed that too many student defense presentations felt like pro forma exercises, lacking authentic student engagement and falling short of the potential of Portfolio Defense. They could see that the Defense — a model designed to empower students — was not working for enough of their students. EA teachers hypothesized that students would be far more engaged and their agency would increase if their identities as learners were more central and if the Defense process were more inclusive and culturally responsive. We hypothesize that with these improvements, students will be better prepared for college, less likely to confront imposter syndrome, and more likely to persist until they earn a degree.
As a result of the EA teachers’ inquiry, in 2018-19 Envision Academy changed the driving question of the Defense to one that asks each student to describe who they were, are, and want to be as a scholar, the kind of person they want to be, and the role of education in shaping their identity. The teachers also found ways for students to bring more of their culture and community into the process, including giving their presentations in their native language. As a result of these changes, other aspects of model changed as well: the senior Advisory curriculum shifted to focus on the Identity Statement, with significant time dedicated to writing and revising; new strategies were put in place to align the Identity Statement with each students’ portfolio of academic artifacts; teachers developed tighter frameworks for assessing projects and calibrated with each other to ensure consistency. These changes led to stronger, more personal defense presentations, richer connections to academic content, and clearer reflections from students about their identities, their goals for the future, and their awareness about their areas of growth.
The improvements we have piloted at EA have already had a strong, positive impact on students. In the words of one graduate: “I was able to express more about myself and my passions in my defense presentation, especially where we explained who we are, who we used to be, and who we want to be. That was very powerful because the presentation wasn’t just academic but also about the student and their goals; it felt more authentic.” Teachers also noticed important changes: “I’ve always thought Portfolio Defense was amazing, but last year was just incredible. The new process really put our students at the center. It was rewarding to see them, in the 2019 presentations, be more engaged and invested; presentations were more personal, and so many more of them presented like scholars. That’s how I know these changes have made a huge difference.”
Anecdotally, these quotes represent what we know is possible: with a more student-centered Portfolio Defense system, our students will be more invested in their education, they will actively develop a scholar-warrior identity, and they will be more prepared to meet the challenges of college and persist through them. With a college degree, they will be positioned to change the economic trajectory of their lives. As these students gain financial autonomy, they can break the cycle of generational poverty, positively impacting the individual student, their families, and their communities more broadly.
In community,
-Gia
Click here for more information about Envision Schools.
This month, watch ELP STEM assessment specialist, Jim Malamut, share his ideas on Proximity of Evidence to student thinking.
Looking for more resources? Visit the ELP blog page for all past newsletter content.
Events
ELP continues to have a strong presence at conferences all over the US in 19-20:
- EdLeader21 conference last month in Houston, Texas. Our Executive Director, Justin Wells, facilitated a breakout session (with a district team from Springfield, MO) called Portrait to Performance with Portfolios.
- iNACOL, also last month, in Palm Springs, California. Our Deeper Learning Coach, Abby Benedetto, delivered the latest version of ELP’s Grad Profile 101 workshop.
Upcoming conferences:
- Assessment for Learning (February 2020) in San Diego, California, mentioned in this newsletter’s ED message. For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. ELP will be hosting workshops throughout the conference focused on Student Exhibitions & Defense of Learning.
Announcements
NEW ELP PARTNERS FOR 19-20
Each school year, ELP welcomes new education partners from across the country. Please join us in welcoming:
- East Palo Alto Academy: ELP will be working with EPAA to synthesize a clear vision for their graduates and build teacher capacity to integrate projects with rigorous assessments of content standards and transferable skills.
- Cleveland Metro Schools: ELP will be partnering with John Adams College & Career Academy to design a system of performance assessments that are aligned with their vision of a graduate and lead the graduating class of 2022 through Portfolio Defenses.
- Davis Joint Unified School District: ELP will be prototyping “defense of learning” systems aligned to the Davis USD Graduate Profile and accelerating the implementation of these systems among a cohort of piloting schools in the district.
- Fairfax County Public Schools: ELP will be assisting this innovative district with their student presentations of learning, providing feedback and an outside perspective.
- Purdue Polytechnic High School: ELP will build on the strengths at Purdue to align a cohesive performance assessment system, culminating in a capstone portfolio and defense.
- IL State Board of Ed: ELP worked with ISBE to identify and implement a project around needed resources, guidance, and support for Illinois to best understand how to provide competency-based education, performance-based assessment, and establish a shared culture of innovation to promote equity for all students. (This represents an opportunity for Illinois-based school districts, so please reach out to learn more.)
GATES FOUNDATION PROFESSIONAL LEARNING PARTNERSHIP GRANT
We are delighted to share that ConnectED and Envision Learning Partners are partnering with the San Diego Unified School District to enhance the integrated sequence of the Illustrative Mathematics high school curriculum. This work is funded by a grant from the Gates Foundation. In collaboration with our partners, we will leverage existing curriculum-embedded instructional resources and parent engagement approaches, elevating strategies that close achievement gaps for English Learners.
I am excited about the upcoming Assessment for Learning Conference and encourage everyone in the performance assessment movement to join us in San Diego this February (11–13th).
For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. Having learned much from being part of this community, ELP has been hungry to see it grow. So we’re thrilled that the Assessment for Learning Project is stepping up to host its first-ever conference. The event will be populated with some of the most innovative, thoughtful, equity-minded, and visionary educators and system leaders when it comes to assessment.
ELP is proud to be a co-designer of the conference, and it’s shaping up to be a cutting-edge learning experience for attendees, who will be challenged to apply innovative assessment principles to their own 3-day learning journey. This is a conference designed for practicing, not preaching.
There are so many educators around the country who are doing incredible work to transform assessment, and this conference is a chance for us to learn with each other and build on the momentum to create an Assessment FOR Learning movement. I hope you will join us!
For more info and to register, go to www.assessmentforlearningconference.org.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
Describe what you do at ELP?
I lead the operations side of Envision Learning Partners. This primarily involves behinds the scenes work to ensure our infrastructure and systems are running smoothly so our coaches can deliver high-quality professional development. ELP’s start-up culture has built our service and systems through many years of relationship building, prototyping, and refining.
What experiences brought you to ELP?
I began my work with Envision as an English teacher at City Arts and Tech [our school in San Francisco]. After stepping out of the classroom, I worked closely with all of our schools in a highly successful reading intervention program. In 2010, I became a founding member of the Envision Learning Partners team. We spent the first several years of ELP figuring out the most high leverage work we could do with our external partners. The journey has been amazing – we’ve grown our service from 3 team members serving 1 partner to 11 team members serving over 60 partners.
What do you enjoy most about working for ELP?
I am driven by the mission of ELP and expanding positive educational impact to all students. I believe deeply in providing access and high-quality learning experiences to all students. At ELP we primarily work with adult learners to refine their teaching practices and educational systems, but my motivation still comes from impacting students’ lives by shifting adult teaching and learning.
What do you like to do when you’re not working?
I spend most of my time on outdoor adventures with my wonderful husband and two children. We like to hike, rock climb, backpack, ski, and camp whenever we have the opportunity. Almost every morning before the sun is up you can find me at a barre class and I always sneak in time to read several novels per month.
What is an accelerator? Accelerator programs are designed to foster and support innovation. They usually have a set timeframe in which individual companies spend anywhere from a few weeks to a few months in an intensive, immersive environment working with a group of mentors to build out their business and avoid problems along the way. [Techrepublic]
What is Tinquevation? to introduce something new and/or to make changes in anything established through seeking knowledge/understanding by questioning/investigation, with the explicit intent to obstruct, threaten, & dismantle systems of oppression.
- A mindset: you can try it at different moments
- A process: it can guide you and remind you to consider different things
- A prototype: it is an idea/concept that will be improved by testing it out
What did you most enjoy about being a coach with ELP?
My favorite thing about being at Envision Learning Partners has been the people. It has been so great to work with a team of people full of such brilliance, integrity, and creativity. Most of the best moments have been during car (or plane) rides between professional development sessions and post-meeting meetings where we’d all talk and argue and learn about each others’ challenges, questions, insights, and strategies for helping schools.
What was your favorite coaching experience?
It is really hard to pick just one favorite coaching experience but, if I had to, it would probably be working with Vinci Daro [ELP’s Director of STEM Learning] and Tamyra Walker [Envision Education’s Director of Math] to build out professional learning programs for the Envision math teachers.
What are your plans now?
My plan is to pursue a Ph.D. in Math Curriculum & Teacher Education so I can, hopefully, learn even more ways to be more useful to schools.
Jim’s Background
As STEM Assessment Specialist at Envision Learning Partners (ELP), Jim played a key role on the ELP STEM team in his work with teachers and school leaders to improve math instruction, connect assessment and learning, and build educator capacity to support students’ language development in the process. Jim came to ELP from Understanding Language/Stanford Center for Assessment, Learning, and Equity (UL/SCALE), which he joined in 2016 after working for two years as a teacher collaborator on SCALE’s PBL curriculum project Learning Through Performance Middle School Mathematics. He taught 6th grade mathematics at East Bay Innovation Academy (Oakland, CA), which uses a combination of blended learning and project-based learning. Before that, he taught at public schools in Philadelphia and in Ghana.
Jim’s experience as a middle school math teacher brings a classroom lens to his work on performance task design, rubric design, analysis of student work, and professional development. Jim’s curriculum development experience includes building language development opportunities into math and science curricula, including the Illustrative Mathematics OER curriculum, and working with the English Learner Success Forum to train curriculum developers in designing materials that attend to both mathematical and language development. His professional development experience includes working with the CALLI (California Language and Learning Innovation) Collaborative project. At ELP, he continued to facilitate professional development empowering math teachers to write high-quality performance assessments. He is also a member of the research team for the Measures of Deeper Learning project, supporting our work with schools engaged in the assessment of social-emotional learning competencies.
Follow Jim on Twitter @JimMalamut.

Farewell, Jim
Hear why our newest Deeper Learning Coach, Morgan Vien, joined ELP and is excited about her new role working with our partners across the country.
Why did you apply for the Deeper Learning Leadership Forum (DLLF)?
[ELP’s Deeper Learning Coach] Alcine had worked with our district for a year, helping us develop our Graduate Profile. During one of our training sessions, she informed me of the DLLF geographic plan to include our area. That year I was also assuming a new role of Director of Pupil Personnel/Equity Officer and felt that the forum would greatly benefit my professional growth as well as the direction of my district.
What are the benefits of being a part of the DLLF?
Learning from a group of diverse educators has been the greatest reward. There are members from large and small districts who are willing to go on the deeper learning/equity journey that will take our school systems to the next level.
How has it helped you with your professional work?
The DLLF experience has provided me with a network of educators that will serve as a professional learning community for 18 months and beyond. The structured and unstructured collaboration has allowed me to introduce ideas in my district that “disrupt” the typical processes of education.
What is your individual project?
Introducing equity systems across my district. Building the concept of equity in our district is definitely in its infancy stages. To complete my project, I used Kotter’s 8 Stages of Change to introduce and implement equitable practices in my district.Robert is the Director of Pupil Personnel and Equity Officer for the Mason County School District in Kentucky.
Learn more about the Deeper Learning Leadership Forum experience by clicking here.
Envision Learning Partners is delighted and honored to introduce Capital High with the Madison Metropolitan School District in Wisconsin. We started our partnership with the district back in 2016, and this year we are thrilled to be working with three of their schools. Karyn Stocks Glover is the principal of Capital High and has shared her thoughts on our work together below.
How are you advancing your Performance Assessment System?
Capital High is guided by an equity vision and four equity drivers that support doing school differently. Capital High is launching its Graduation by Portfolio Performance Assessment this year. With the support and expertise of our Envision Learning Partners (ELP), we are designing a portfolio model that is aligned to competencies identified in the Madison Metropolitan School District’s graduate vision, that is specifically focused on growth mindset as a critical driver for deeper learning, and that is incorporated in all areas of learning through our Core Benchmarks (see in Appendix).
Madison Metropolitan School District’s Graduate Profile
Our participation in the Tinquevation Accelerator Workshop this summer with ELP supported us to engage in designing at the margins, and an outcome of this five-day intensive was naming and claiming growth mindset as a core value and a core practice across all areas of teaching and learning. Recognizing that our students and staff are inherently resilient, we framed our growth mindset skills (curiosity, planning, risk-taking, reflection) in this core belief. We are beginning to develop rubrics for our performance assessment system, which we will do in partnership with ELP.
We will have our first portfolio defenses in May 2020. Over the next two years, we will continue to partner with ELP in order to expand our graduation by portfolio model to include self-knowledge and interpersonal skills.
What have you learnt during this process?
We have learned doing school differently means defining deeper learning through asking students what they need to be successful in the long term and in the moment, and through supporting teachers to work in teams that prioritize student demonstration of mastery in knowledge and skills over time and through multiple opportunities in a variety of academic settings. We have learned that we thrive through shared leadership.
What is the impact you are seeing on students and their work?
Our students are building trust with their peers and the adults who support them; they are learning that Capital High is a community that believes completely in their innate goodness and intelligence, and that their voices are valued. We are seeing evidence of students being thoughtfully reflective about their learning through the lens of growth mindset.
What is the impact you are seeing on teachers and their practice?
Staff choose to work at Capital High because our goal to do school differently aligns with their values and because they want to work in professional partnership with their peers. Staff recognize that teaching skills versus content, measuring progress versus outcomes, and embracing collaboration versus isolation require curiosity, planning, risk taking and reflection with peers. Capital High staff are applying a growth mindset in their own practices.
What is the impact of this work ON YOU as a practitioner?
As the founding principal of Capital High, I value the partnership with ELP to support our journey to do school differently. While I brought a number of leadership strengths to the role, I have found that my capacity for leading transformational change is enhanced by working with an organization that has always prioritized identity work through student voice and student growth. I appreciate that ELP is not a model one adopts, but rather a way of working that centers race and equity and applies design thinking (where you are encouraged to design at the margins) so that schools can write their own stories.
APPENDIX
Capital High’s Equity Vision
Empowered by personalized learning in a diverse and supportive community, and strengthened by family and school partnerships, all students will graduate prepared to succeed on their individual pathway.
Who We Are
Capital High is a non-traditional high school that is committed to deeper learning in the Madison Metropolitan School District. Our work is guided by the district’s Strategic Framework and Graduate Vision, as well as our school’s equity vision. We have an unwavering commitment to racial equity and an ambitious plan to serve opportunity youth. Our mission is to change the narrative for opportunity youth by providing learning through interests opportunities and preparing youth for post-secondary success in college and career.
We are engaged in a school design and development process that is fortified by a dedicated staff who are deeply committed to transformational change – individually, collectively, and institutionally. Disciplined and thoughtful professional collaboration is a standard of practice at Capital High. Together, we are creating and sustaining a thriving school community that is anchored in its commitment to anti-racist values and learning partnerships with students and families.
Our Approach
Our approach prioritizes opportunities and practices for youth engagement through student involvement and shared power. Our work is guided by four equity drivers – competency teaching and learning, advisory, experiential learning, and professional collaboration. These transformational change drivers support our commitment to a clear vision with targeted strategies and are embedded in “fail forward, fail fast” practices of innovation in service of opportunity youth. Our academic competency model is aligned to Common Core State Standards and articulated through measurable benchmarks of college readiness. Our advisory model prioritizes student agency through goal setting and reflection, as well as developing well being through relationships to self and others. Our experiential learning model promotes student inquiry and exploration of higher education, career pathways, and community partnerships. Our professional collaboration model is built on the belief that through collective efficacy we improve the lives of all members of our school community. Students graduate by portfolio with multiple opportunities to meet and exceed competencies in mastery of content and growth mindset.
ELP hosted its first “Tinquevation” Summer Accelerator, piloting a new structure that supports system design and transformation. The week-long experience was attended by Design Teams from 4 of the Envision Schools, and a client school from Madison, WI, Capital High. Click here to read more about Capital High, as Karyn Stocks Glover, principal of Capital High, shares her thoughts on our work together.
Design Teams consisted of school leaders, teacher leaders, and student leaders who came together in downtown Oakland to be in community together as we investigated how to re-imagine our systems with an uncompromising priority of putting equity at the center.
The Accelerator borrowed structures from the world of technology and start-ups to try and create spaces for people to learn deeply and then to immediately prototype applying that learning to their own contexts.
Each morning started with informative and diverse panels of speakers representing voices that we need to inspire and push our thinking – alumni, business leaders, higher education folks, etc. Personal and collective equity work was woven throughout each day, and thanks to the leadership of ELP coach, Alcine Mumby, it became clear that the most important work we need to do is to center the voices of our most marginalized in our systems.
One of the most impactful dimensions to the Accelerator was the uplifting and centering of student voice. Not surprisingly, having students at the table who felt invited and supported in speaking authentically about their lived experience within our systems was the richest content created during the week.
Teams left the Accelerator with plans to locate the most marginalized voices at each school and to engage in deep and relational empathy with these folks in order to better understand their realities, their needs, and their asks for changes to be made. Our school teams developed a clear path forward after the accelerator:
- Envision Design Teams will meet with each other throughout the academic year as they dig into an inquiry project about what the Graduate Profile should be for Envision Schools, and how can it live more at the center of our system.
- Capital High is mapping backward from their first round of Graduation Portfolio Defenses that will take place in May, during which their students will reflect deeply on how they have understood and practiced Growth Mindset in their lives in and outside of school.
The Accelerator planning is being wonderfully lead by ELP team member, Abby Benedetto, learn more about her in this post, and is being supported by a long-time deeper learning colleague and thought leader around equity in education, Shane Safir.
ELP looks forward to the next iteration of the Accelerator, stay tuned for more details.
The September Newsletter’s Resource Corner provides some of the slides from the Accelerator and to read more about its development, click here.
LOOKING FOR THE NEXT DLLF COHORT!
ELP is pleased to announce that applications and nominations for the fourth cohort of The Deeper Learning Leadership Forum (DLLF) will be open on October 1st!
The DLLF is a cohort-based leadership experience that aims to develop, strengthen, and support a group of educational leaders to work at the intersection of equity and design thinking. We invite you to contribute your expertise and passion to this collective effort to increase educational equity.
For more information click here and view the Guest Blog here, written by Cohort 3 member, Robert Moore.
AMPLIFIED LABS JOINS ELP AS A STRATEGIC PARTNER
Each year, ELP works with schools, districts, and states to help them in their journey to deploying High-Quality Performance Assessment Systems. We are often asked by our partners what digital student portfolio systems can we recommend. Based on our work in districts that have adopted the platform, we believe Amplified IT’s Backpack for Google Drive is a promising system for students to curate, reflect upon, and showcase digital learning artifacts against a district-defined skills framework.
FAREWELL, JIM
Deeper Learning Coach, Jim Malamut, left ELP this summer to pursue a Ph.D. in Math Curriculum & Teacher Education at Stanford to learn even more ways he can help support schools. Read more about Jim and his favorite ELP coaching moments here.
Sometimes it’s important, in our jargon-loving profession, to put things as plainly we can. That’s certainly true for a concept such as performance assessment.
A word that comes in handy is the word challenge. I use it for two key questions:
The first is, How are we challenging our students?
Schools and districts that are consciously building a performance assessment system tend to have crisp answers to that question: “We challenge our students to do a year-long research project.” “Our 3rd graders plan and facilitate their own conferences.” “11th graders must design and implement a statistical analysis with help from an outside expert.” “Our kids have to defend their learning every two years.”
The second question is then, How are we challenging ourselves and our system to prepare our students for their challenges?
Again, I am encouraged by crisp answers: “We look at student work and calibrate on our rubrics once per month.” “Our grade level teams meet in the summer to design two multi-disciplinary projects per year.” “The science department will be using a Next-Gen-aligned rubric for assessing inquiry projects next year.” “We’re investing in PD so that our teachers can teach public speaking across the curriculum.”
Try it. As you build your performance assessment system, keep asking, “How are we challenging our students?” and “How are we challenging ourselves?” Tighten up your answers. Then live them.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
What experiences brought you into coaching?
I had the incredible experience to be on the team that founded Envision Learning Partners. I was half-way into my teaching career at that point and was offered the opportunity to design and create a way in which we could share some of what makes Envision special with others around the country who were interested. I spent 2 years feeling like I had gone back to grad school as we built ELP, as I was learning so much in the process! Wanting to put into practice for myself all of the rich growth I had experienced, I went back into the classroom at Envision for 5 more years. It was a natural and wonderful return to coaching in 2016 when I was able to re-join the team on this side of the organization.
What do you most enjoy about being a coach?
I feel so inspired by the brilliant educators with whom I get to cross paths and sit shoulder to shoulder while on my coaching journey. I was worried that I would miss the beautiful chaos of teenagers on a daily basis when I left teaching, but coaching provides similarly vibrant relationships with the folks I get to partner with. Coaching offers a bit of a different cognitive challenge as I get to think about units of change larger than my own classroom. This is invigorating and often makes my brain hurt in really cool ways.
What do you like to do when you are not coaching?
When not on a plane or sitting in an airport, you can find me running the trails of the incredible hills and redwood forests in the east bay, talking to every dog I pass on the sidewalk, enjoying the incredible food and wine that we have at our fingertips, traveling to far off magical lands as often as possible, cooking dinner for former students, and stepping out on a dance floor when the music is right.
Historically, education has been the least nimble of all of our institutions. Walk into classrooms across the country and many of them have not changed significantly in 150 years. We are trying to shift the way that schools organize and engage all students in meaningful deeper learning so that every young person has the skills they need to be their most fully expressed selves as they go out into the world. The Summer Accelerator borrows structures that support innovation and rapid prototyping from the tech and business sectors. This will be an intensive, immersive experience during which inclusive school design teams consisting of adults and students will learn, imagine, and plan for how we might redesign school models to better serve all students.
We are using an equity-centered design model for both the experience that the teams will go through, as well as for the lens through which they will be designing. There will be structured learning experiences in the first half of each day, and supported work time/office hours with access to experts in the second half. Each day will end with some type of feedback loop during which teams will present something with which they are grappling and receive thought partnership from the larger group so that they can move forward the following day. By the final day, each team will leave with a prototype of a Graduate Profile, performance outcomes associated with each skill they selected, and a plan for what component of their system they will begin to test the prototype. The school design teams will come from the 5 Envision Education schools: Envision Academy High School and Middle Grades in Oakland, City Arts & Technology High School in San Francisco, and Impact Academy of Arts & Technology High School and Middle Grades in Hayward, as well as from one of our client schools in Madison, WI.
Each school design team is intended to be as representative of diverse voices and perspectives as possible. Schools are required to bring teams that include at least the following: 1 administrator, 2 teachers from different grade/subject/experience levels, and 2 students from different grade/experience levels. Schools may choose to add more to their teams if possible and/or relevant. This will be the first year that we are piloting the Summer Accelerator, so we are wanting to keep the participant list manageable and targeted to schools who are in a similar phase of readiness for transformation.
The mission of Envision Schools is to transform the lives of students – especially those who will be first in their family to attend college – by preparing them for success in college, career, and life. Our high schools were all created with an arts & technology focus in terms of curriculum because we believe that young people need skills of creativity and technology in order to be successful in today and tomorrow’s jobs. Our students primarily come from underrepresented populations in tech – 75% of them qualify for free and reduced lunch, 72% of them will be first in their family to attend college, and 90% are students of color. We are working to create systems of education that allow all students to see themselves in any career of their choosing, specifically encouraging them to consider tech and tech-related fields as vibrant and viable options. The goal of the Summer Accelerator is to situate equity at the center of our thinking and planning at every level such that we work towards creating more inclusive educational systems for students in Oakland and beyond.
The Accelerator planning is being wonderfully lead by ELP team member, Abby, learn more about her in this post, and is being supported by a long-time deeper learning colleague and thought leader around equity in education, Shane Safir.
Envision Learning Partners started working with Bryan Adams High School (Dallas, Texas) four years ago to help them transition their entire High School of 2,000 students to a Performance Assessment System. MaryAnn Suhl (Bryan Adams Vice Principal and the lead on this transition) shares her experiences on the project in this blog post:
How are you advancing your Performance Assessment System?
Since we began implementing our Performance Assessment System, we have continued to evolve it into something that works for our campus. Our Performance Assessment system is so beneficial and powerful for our students. When we host defenses, students want to stand in front of their peers, administrators, family members and the community so that they have an opportunity to share their story. It is something so transformative for our students, but also has had a major impact on our teachers because they can now see what students learned in their classes. In some cases, it has caused our teachers to rethink what and how they are teaching based on student defenses and performance assessments.
What have you learnt during this process?
Robot match for engineering students that was a performance assessment in their class
We have learned that this process takes time and that you have to keep it simple. It is important to create as much buy-in and support from all levels of staff so that it doesn’t become an initiative that “they are making them do” instead of what is best for students and their learning. Finally, don’t give up. You will hit snags and run into some roadblocks but the payoff in student learning and engagement makes the struggle so worthwhile.
What is the impact you are seeing on students and their work?
The direct impact is that students are being provided with greater opportunities to discuss the work they are doing in their classes and how it will impact and relate to what they want to do once they graduate high school. Now that we are four years into this process, it has become the thing that is done and students are now excited to participate in defending their learning and are excited to have a greater sense of purpose in what they are learning.
What is the impact you are seeing on teachers and their practice?
There has also been an unintended consequence of moving to performance assessments and defenses and having all of our faculty serve on defense panels to evaluate students on their ability to articulate their learning: Teachers at our campus now have a greater sense of ownership in the process and can now witness students struggle to describe their learning. In other words, it has caused deep reflections in our faculty on what and how they are teaching because it brought to light a realization that “hey, that is a really cool project and students loved getting to make it, but now I can see that they didn’t actually learn from it what the teacher intended – that is so powerful.” This awareness for students and teachers has brought a more critical and analytical lens to the assessments that our teachers are designing for students. The direct impact has been higher levels of rigor for so many of our classrooms and projects. Students can now engage in meaningful and relatable work – they can better articulate how it will help them in their futures.
Performance Task in Health Class
What is the impact of this work on you as a practitioner?
It has really forced me to rethink teaching and learning at the secondary level to consider the question of how are we really preparing our students for life after high school. As a teacher you spend days, weeks, and sometimes months on an assessment that you are so passionate about and think that it is well-structured and designed intricately so that your students are able to master all of the topics you’ve developed. It’s incredibly rewarding to watch students stand in front of their peers (defending their learning) and say things that are so profound, making deep connections to the lessons and to their own personal lives. Students describe how learning these skills, they feel that they are now better equipped to function in society – there is nothing like it. This experience makes me want performance assessments to be standard practice in all classrooms across the country. I have witnessed the true power of engaged learning that takes place when students have to demonstrate what they know, what they can do, and finally, reflect on how their learning has shaped themselves and their future. I am excited to take this learning and experience to more schools in our district to help other educators begin to see the power of performance assessments.
Teacher-leaders working together on creative solutions to develop performance assessments
Is there one story you can share that illustrates how this work is benefitting your school and your students?
This past year, I was sitting in a senior defense and a young lady stated that she had been accepted to nursing school and her performance assessments she discussed were mostly related to her career in the medical field. What was so profound is that this young lady was able to articulate the learning she participated in her classes, particularly in her science classes. She had a strong understanding of the ways in which learning that information in her classes was going to be very beneficial as she was embarking upon nursing school. She also was very candid about how she thought during her freshman year that defenses and performance assessments were silly and just extra projects. She didn’t think they were connected at all to leadership or preparing her for her future. Now she does.
This year’s Defense Design Studios (DDS), our annual portfolio defense showcases, are all completed! These events might have been the closing for the students who presented but for a lot of the educators who attended, it’s just beginning. Many of this year’s attendees are looking to implement portfolio defenses into their schools.
Two visitors from The Edge Foundation, based in London, attended the DDS at Envision Academy in Oakland and later wrote about the portfolio defense model and their experience at observing our students. Read their reflection here.
ELP hosts DDS at Envision schools in the Bay Area, as well as partner schools in Sacramento and Dallas. There are even a few schools in LAUSD that hosted their own DDS without ELP’s support this year, for the first time! Texas saw attendees all the way from Missouri, Sacramento had teams from Fresno and Colorado, and Envision schools gladly welcomed groups from Wisconsin, New York, and even the UK. All in all, over 100 educators attended the ELP hosted DDS this year.
TEAM UPDATES
The ELP team had a full and exciting year in 2018-19:
- Two of our team members (Alcine and Aragon) joined the inaugural Nexus Fellowship to further develop ELP’s equity stance through equityXdesign – a practice that merges the consciousness of racial equity work with the methodology of design thinking.
- ELP’s launched our first Summer Accelerator (designed and led by Abby): an intensive, immersive experience during which inclusive school design teams consisting of adults and students learn, imagine, and plan for how we might redesign school models to better serve all students.
- ELP recognized the need to spend more time together to refine our programs and learn from each other’s practice – Learning Days was launched in May, led by Abby, bringing our coaches together monthly from across the country.
- We added two members to our talented team: Aragon Burlingham joined at the beginning of the year as Director of Partnerships, and Morgan Vien joined at the end of the year as a Deeper Learning coach.
- Finally, ELP focused its talented coaches (Jim and Vinci) inwards to help our own Envision Schools develop deeper content learning in mathematics.
GEOGRAPHIC REACH
ELP added 20 cities to it’s operational reach this fiscal year, totaling 56 cities in the US and one in Beijing. ELP also quadrupled its support of State Departments, working with Virginia last year, and serving Ohio, Kentucky, and Colorado this year.
BLOG RELAUNCH
ELP is relaunching our blog – keep up with past newsletter content, including more in-depth articles and shared resources! Click on any of the section titles in the newsletter for a quick link to that blog post.
ELP IN THE NEWS
ELP was recently highlighted in an EdWeek article, thanks to a partnership between two of our team members, Ruth Chung Wei & Vinci Daro, and a charter school in Washington DC. Two Rivers Public Charter School started offering a 12-month program for teachers focused on better defining, teaching, and assessing critical thinking and problem-solving skills. Ruth and Vinci provided feedback to the cohort members on their assessment task designs.
ELP is thrilled to welcome Morgan Vien to our team of Deeper Learning Coaches. Fabulously talented and exploding with ideas, Morgan complements our team with her experience in K-8 school leadership (most recently, serving as principal at ASCEND School in Oakland) and facilitating design thinking (as a School Retool Coach for Stanford’s d.school). We, and our client partners, are going to learn so much from her. Please welcome Morgan when you see her out in the field.
In other ELP news, we recently hatched a new strategic plan, our first since joining forces with the Stanford Center for Assessment, Learning, and Equity (SCALE) over a year and a half ago. ELP’s vision—every student in America is learning within a high-quality performance assessment system—is ambitious in scale and generational in scope, so we know we need to set ourselves up for the long haul. In the coming three years, our strategic priorities are:
- to grow our service to American public school districts, the primary agent of educational delivery in this country.
- to expand the ways that we serve our client partners so that they have more pathways to success.
- to ensure that equity is not only the reason for this work but also the process of how we do this work.
- to catalyze research on the impact of high-quality performance assessment systems on student learning.
- to establish the sustainability of our business model so that we can deliver on our mission indefinitely.
As always, we welcome your thought partnership. Let us know what you think about our plan, or ask any one of us to elaborate when our paths cross in the field.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
9 Tips for Writing Effective Rubrics – Adapted from the important thinking of our partners at SCALE, this tool attempts to capture the quality criteria of solid rubric design. The tool is helping our partner schools all over the country to develop performance indicators that serve to define proficiency for their Graduate Profile skills. Take a look and share with us any quality criteria you’ve found effective!
Measuring what Matters, Learning by Doing, and Piloting with Purpose
There is statewide support for Deeper Learning in Colorado, and Envision Learning Partners is playing a key role.
In 2007, the state of Colorado asked districts to choose the ways their students will demonstrate college and career readiness, and therefore readiness to graduate from high school.
This Graduation Guidelines menu lists the options. In the mix of more traditional tests, two options provide a clear pathway for students to graduate by demonstrating their skills through an individualized product or presentation: Capstone Projects and Collaboratively Developed Standards-Based Performance Assessment.
Coaching Deeper Learning in Colorado
Since April 2018, Envision Learning Partners has been honored and energized to work in an accelerated way with educators at every level of the Colorado educational system, to design meaningful and sustainable assessment systems worthy of and accessible to every student in Colorado, strongly aligned to the demands of a wide variety of 21st century college and career options.
This June marks the close of two incredible first-year partnerships between ELP and the Colorado Department of Education, as well as the Colorado Education Initiative; both projects involve educators from every corner of the state to transform education statewide.
Transitions and Opportunities for Envision Learning Partners
Dear ELP Community:
I am writing with news about a transition for Envision Learning Partners. This past year has been eventful for us (as I am sure it has been for you). We onboarded a new Executive Director and a new Assessment Design Partner. We completed strategic plan processes for both Envision Learning Partners and Envision Education org-wide. We are about to finish a 3-month study of our impact and ways to expand it. Now, as we wrap up the school year, we consider the future and make decisions about how to navigate education’s changing times and shifting landscapes.
Royce Conner, ELP’s Executive Director, will be transitioning from his role on June 30th. We are grateful to Royce for the important contributions he has made and projects he has led during his tenure, and we deeply support him as he moves into the next chapter of his distinguished career as an educator. Feel free to connect with Royce on LinkedIn.
Royce’s responsibilities will be distributed across Envision Education as part of a comprehensive org-wide strategy to deepen the integration between our schools (our local impact) and our consulting service (our nationwide impact). Out in the field, our remarkable team of coaches and operations professionals will continue to help school districts build high-quality performance assessment systems. In my role as Chief Program Officer, I am excited for the opportunity and the commitment to make the sum of “One Envision” to be greater than its already powerful parts.
As we head into the summer, when educators often feel a welcome shift in pace, I invite you to reach out to me with questions or wonders. ELP remains your steadfast partner in our movement to bring high-quality performance assessment to all students.
In community,

Justin Wells, Chief Program Officer
In a recent conversation with fellow advocates of performance assessment, a colleague made the point that our job as educators is not to teach standards but to teach students.
Of course, standards play an important role in guiding teachers’ work. But given the structures and incentives of our system, it’s easy for standards to slip into the position of ends rather than means. Tragically, covering standards—“I taught it; some got it.”—feeds inequities that plague education. When we truly reorient to “teaching students,” we stay focused on those whole human beings in our classrooms. What do our students need to achieve, how will we know they have achieved it, and how do we support their getting there? This is performance assessment system design.
The graduate profile movement is a boon, pushing students into the focal point of our energies. Social-emotional learning (SEL) is trending, reminding us to attend to the whole child. But none of these ideas will translate into lived learning experiences until students are regularly tackling rigorous and real-world challenges that elicit the skills they need to practice and master. Our kids need high-quality performance assessments.
Join us on twitter for more conversation about the importance of teaching students over standards, using the hashtag #TeachStudentsNotStandards
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
During his keynote at last fall’s EdLeader21 Conference, educational thought leader, Tony Wagner, did not mince words. “A graduate portrait without an assessment,” he said, “is useless.”
The audience members—mainly district leaders from around the country—audibly shifted in their seats. Although it’s hard to disagree, it’s also hard to pull off. How can school districts assess skills that are as complex as the ones we see on a typical graduate profile?
Tony followed up his challenge with two recommendations:
- “Every student should have a digital portfolio.”
- “Every student should present or defend their learning.”
He’s right. Portfolio assessment and presentations of learning (which come in many forms, including defenses and student-led conferences) are two effective, customizable, scalable, and actionable ways to move from “poster to practice.”
ELP cheers the graduate profile movement because of its potential to change our society’s conception of education’s purpose. But we also worry for the movement. If we don’t see graduate profiles made visible in the actual work of our students—“show don’t tell,” says this old English teacher—then we’re destined to look back on this as another edu-trend that came to nothing. That’s why Tony Wagner’s admonition is so urgent.
The challenge of assessing graduate profiles is one of the major themes of next month’s Assessment for Learning Conference. I know I will see many of you there, and I am excited for the opportunity to work on this together.

Justin Wells,
ELP Executive Director
ELP is thrilled to welcome Morgan Vien to our team of Deeper Learning Coaches. Fabulously talented and exploding with ideas, Morgan complements our team with her experience in K-8 school leadership (most recently, serving as principal at ASCEND School in Oakland) and facilitating design thinking (as a School Retool Coach for Stanford’s d.school). We, and our client partners, are going to learn so much from her. Please welcome Morgan when you see her out in the field.
In other ELP news, we recently hatched a new strategic plan, our first since joining forces with the Stanford Center for Assessment, Learning, and Equity (SCALE) over a year and a half ago. ELP’s vision—every student in America is learning within a high-quality performance assessment system—is ambitious in scale and generational in scope, so we know we need to set ourselves up for the long haul. In the coming three years, our strategic priorities are:
- to grow our service to American public school districts, the primary agent of educational delivery in this country.
- to expand the ways that we serve our client partners so that they have more pathways to success.
- to ensure that equity is not only the reason for this work but also the process of how we do this work.
- to catalyze research on the impact of high-quality performance assessment systems on student learning.
- to establish the sustainability of our business model so that we can deliver on our mission indefinitely.
As always, we welcome your thought partnership. Let us know what you think about our plan, or ask any one of us to elaborate when our paths cross in the field.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
The COVID crisis deepens. All of us engaged in the endeavor of learning—students and teachers—now gather ourselves for what we know will be a strange, trying, and unpredictable school year ahead.
As your learning community makes its mad design dash to the start of the school year, with all your contingency plans and spreadsheets and multiple scenarios, don’t forget to keep your graduate profile, or whatever serves as your overarching set of desired learning outcomes, close at hand. Refer often to that list, and keep asking, How are we designing ways for our students to practice these skills?
This pandemic is driving home the pre-pandemic truth that learning is not about seat time or content delivery or testing, all of which crumbled with startling quickness last spring. Learning has always been and will always be about improving one’s skills through practice, guided by coaching. Conceived as such, learning is remarkably flexible. Practice, guided by coaching, can happen at home independently, or on a video call, or in a sparsely desked classroom with children in masks. Establish practice routines for the key skills of your course. Introduce them as early as possible in the school year. Design those routines to be portable, and demonstrate that portability to your students by simulating at-home practice when you have them in your classrooms, and in-classroom practice when you have them on a video call.
I have more to say about elevating the “practice question” in a blog I recently contributed to our friends at Future Focused Education.
We can rise to this challenge, especially if we apply the principles of High-Quality Performance Assessment, and we can make school better than it was before.
In solidarity with educators everywhere,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
Have you had a chance to read Jal Mehta’s piece in Ed Week, “Why Equity Has Been a Conservative Force in American Education—And How That Could Change”? If you haven’t, you should.
Mehta argues that “the effort to close achievement gaps has in practice doubled down on the century-old industrial model of schooling, leaving in place all of the essential elements of its grammar: teaching as transmission, batch processing of students, conventional assessments, tracking and leveling, and all of the rest. Anything that moves away from those assumptions—like project-based learning, problem-based learning, interdisciplinary learning, authentic assessment, or constructivist pedagogy—is seen as ‘risky;’ something that is ‘OK for the privileged kids’ but somehow distracts from the real work of closing achievement gaps on state-sponsored tests.”
We at Envision Learning Partners see deeper learning not as a risk but as a moral imperative, not only because all children deserve it, but also because it’s the right way to make change. I agree with Mehta’s notion of “liberatory design,” which “assumes that teachers and students would like to develop engaging, meaningful learning experiences, and that the problem is not them but the institutional structures and culture of schools that constrains them.” I am fortunate to witness proof of this regularly in my work when, for example, I see the excitement among students and teachers who have designed and implemented a portfolio-defense system.
The teachers and leaders who reach out to partner with ELP have drawn similar conclusions about deeper learning. We are proud to serve their schools and districts, and we are always inspired by their courage to do this work.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
As you work furiously and heroically to serve your students through the COVID-19 crisis, ELP offers this advice: Don’t forget about your graduate profile. Now’s the time to lean into it.
It doesn’t matter whether your performance assessment system is well established or just getting off the ground, whether you’re currently reaching your students through Zoom or printed worksheet packets. If your learning community has a graduate profile or similar set of learner outcomes, you should use that language to remind your students of their assets and to challenge them to grow. Most graduate profiles were designed to focus us on the skills students need to navigate a fast-changing world with an unpredictable future. Now we get to put them to the test.
Many graduate or learner profiles, for example, target a competency that has to do with being a “self-directed learner.” Let’s admit that it’s a concept more aspirational than operational. In most of our highly-structured learning environments, young people have very little opportunity to practice being self-directed. Guess what? Now they need it. And we need to teach it. So invoke the skill, express high expectations for students to develop the skill during this time, give them ideas for how to practice and demonstrate it, structure opportunities for them to reflect on it, and challenge them to document evidence of their growth. This goes for any skill that’s on your graduate profile.
Stay tuned. In coming weeks, ELP will continue to share suggestions for ways to leverage or advance the elements of your performance assessment system: the use of portfolios, running defenses of learning virtually, building a culture of revision and reflection. There are enormous opportunities in this crisis for students to practice and be assessed on the skills we say are important.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
The Practice Question
Across education, I see the development of a healthy habit, and the performance assessment movement deserves plenty of credit for it. Educators everywhere, when considering a desired learning outcome, are reflexively asking, “How would we measure that?”
This is good. Asking the measurement question holds us accountable to our goals; answering it points us to actions.
But there’s another question that is just as focusing, should be just as reflexive, and would not hurt to come first: “How will our students practice that skill?”
Answer the practice question, and the measurement answer comes easily. It’s not so easy the other way around.
As a young teacher, I too often measured things that my students didn’t get to practice. I whipped out a public speaking rubric when students presented at the front of the room. I assessed them on their volume and eye contact. But we hadn’t practiced those skills in class.
Collaboration shows up on most graduate profiles. How will our students practice that skill? Answer it honestly. Assigning some group work is not the same thing as practicing collaboration.
Another grad profile meme—critical thinking—is not any kind of thinking. It’s grappling with “How might I be wrong?” How do students practice that skill? If a student has gone through a school year without consciously changing her mind on anything, then I doubt she has really practiced critical thinking.
I applaud what I see announced on graduate profiles all over the country—really important skills that schools can help kids get better at: inquiry, citizenship, creativity, persistence, problem solving, cultural competence, and so on. But it’s not fair to measure things that students haven’t had an opportunity to practice.
A high-quality performance assessment system knows its desired outcomes and its measurements; it also takes responsibility for scheduling practice.
Please share with us one of your favorite ways to help your students practice a key skill!
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
The “yes buts”—the common objections to performance assessment—keep dropping away.
The latest comes with the revolutionary announcement from the UC Board of Regents last week: Going forward, the SAT or ACT test is not required for admission to a UC campus. The requirement will be phased out completely by 2025.
And just like that, there goes the “yes but the SAT” counterargument to performance assessment system building. An institutional practice that had seemed entrenched is now revealed by the pandemic to be fragile.
We can add the SAT to a growing list that includes “Yes but instructional minutes,” “Yes but the end-of-year standardized tests,” and “Yes but the course grade.”
Meanwhile, the concept of a defense of learning has proven resilient in this crisis. ELP is proud to partner with the Learning Policy Institute and the Linked Learning Alliance to launch the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series, which in coming weeks presents multiple opportunities to observe students’ virtual defenses of learning and engage in conversations with the inspiring students and educators who have remained committed to performance assessment despite school closures. (For those of you wondering about ELP’s long running practice of Defense Design Studios, this series is where we are putting that energy this year.)
Watch this web page closely for upcoming dates associated with the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series. There are some events happening later this week. And more will be added as plans get solidified. Students and schools are moving fast. Don’t take it from us: Watch Envision student Dani Martin vlog about preparing for her virtual defense. I can’t wait to witness what students have to say about their learning in the next couple weeks, and to discuss the implications of this with all of you in the months to come.
Stay safe,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
Here at Envision Learning Partners, we believe that every student deserves to learn within a high-quality performance assessment system. That means every student goes to a school where:
- targeted skills are announced (often in the form a graduate profile),
- rubrics are widely shared and regularly used,
- teachers are aligned on the quality of assignments and student work,
- students can explain what they are doing and how they are growing,
- and high expectations are not random or tracked; they are held for every student who attends that school.
If a school does not have these conditions in place, or isn’t actively working toward them, then I hesitate to call it a good school, no matter how high its test scores, shiny its hallways, or champion-like its teachers.
We in the performance assessment movement must clamor for focus on the quality of our students’ work—not proxies for their work, like test scores or classroom observations, but the work itself. How are you focusing on and highlighting your students’ work? Drop us a line to let us know!
I invite you to read more of my thoughts on the subject in “What Is a Good School?,” a short piece I wrote for EdWeek’s Learning Deeply blog.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
I am excited about the upcoming Assessment for Learning Conference and encourage everyone in the performance assessment movement to join us in San Diego this February (11–13th).
For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. Having learned much from being part of this community, ELP has been hungry to see it grow. So we’re thrilled that the Assessment for Learning Project is stepping up to host its first-ever conference. The event will be populated with some of the most innovative, thoughtful, equity-minded, and visionary educators and system leaders when it comes to assessment.
ELP is proud to be a co-designer of the conference, and it’s shaping up to be a cutting-edge learning experience for attendees, who will be challenged to apply innovative assessment principles to their own 3-day learning journey. This is a conference designed for practicing, not preaching.
There are so many educators around the country who are doing incredible work to transform assessment, and this conference is a chance for us to learn with each other and build on the momentum to create an Assessment FOR Learning movement. I hope you will join us!
For more info and to register, go to www.assessmentforlearningconference.org.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
A high school principal recently lamented to me that many of his students’ grades are cratering during this time of distance learning. Much of the problem, he observes, is coming from classes whose grades are calculated using points.
Work is assigned, work is not received, and the work gets a zero in the grade book. After that, it’s out of the teacher’s hands. Simple math takes over. Average up the points. Out spits the failing grade.
Keeping our students engaged when we can’t serve them in person has, understandably, proven a challenge. Around the country, teachers are Zooming real hard and feeling disappointed by what they are getting back from students in return. But that problem is compounded by points-based grading systems, which the pandemic has exposed as a pervasive practice in our schools.
Where I see a course that organizes itself around points and percentages, I usually find a learning environment in which the teacher and the students do not share clear answers to simple questions of purpose: What are our learning goals? What are the skills we are focused on improving? What are the ways that students can demonstrate their progress?
Two principles of ELP’s High-Quality Performance Assessment (HQPA) framework are particularly germane here: 1) tight on criteria for success and 2) open to different learner approaches. In a course that is rooted in HQPA, students can describe what success looks like with words, not numbers. And the teacher can point out different paths to success. In such a course, there is no reason why a student cannot, in a single, convincing performance of the targeted skills, redeem a whole semester’s worth of struggle.
If there’s one educational practice that I wish this pandemic would eradicate, it is the use of points for calculating course grades. Its disappearance would be a major advance toward an educational system where assessment is for learning, not for sorting.
With respect and gratitude for the work of educators everywhere.
Sometimes it’s important, in our jargon-loving profession, to put things as plainly we can. That’s certainly true for a concept such as performance assessment.
A word that comes in handy is the word challenge. I use it for two key questions:
The first is, How are we challenging our students?
Schools and districts that are consciously building a performance assessment system tend to have crisp answers to that question: “We challenge our students to do a year-long research project.” “Our 3rd graders plan and facilitate their own conferences.” “11th graders must design and implement a statistical analysis with help from an outside expert.” “Our kids have to defend their learning every two years.”
The second question is then, How are we challenging ourselves and our system to prepare our students for their challenges?
Again, I am encouraged by crisp answers: “We look at student work and calibrate on our rubrics once per month.” “Our grade level teams meet in the summer to design two multi-disciplinary projects per year.” “The science department will be using a Next-Gen-aligned rubric for assessing inquiry projects next year.” “We’re investing in PD so that our teachers can teach public speaking across the curriculum.”
Try it. As you build your performance assessment system, keep asking, “How are we challenging our students?” and “How are we challenging ourselves?” Tighten up your answers. Then live them.
Sincerely,
Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director
One widespread way that schools have adapted to the pandemic, particularly at the secondary level, is a dramatic restructuring of the “bell schedule.” In the virtual and hybrid contexts we’re now operating in, many students are taking, and teachers are teaching, fewer classes at one time, typically made possible by shortening the length of courses or chunking them into alternating modules (which is what we are doing here at Envision Schools).
The challenges are obvious: These new schedules are born of compromise. They are harder to manage for some disciplines than others. Abrupt change is exhausting. But they do present an opportunity for advancing a key element of your performance assessment system—the culture of reflection and revision among teachers.
In a functioning performance assessment system, students’ work (their response to assignments) informs teachers’ work (their design of assignments) in a process that is collaborative and continual. With courses on faster cycles, there are more opportunities to iterate. A semester-long course, if offered twice during the year, doubles the pace of iteration.
Let’s acknowledge that making time for collaborative revision of courses is not easy. Right now, the brute logistics of delivering instruction in the midst of a pandemic are monopolizing our energies. But as we get deeper into the fall, ELP urges educators to dedicate some of your precious PD time, in whatever form it comes, to sharing assessments and analyzing student work, building your system’s muscles for reflection and revision.
Shorter courses demand even crisper answers to the questions that never go away: What do students need to learn, and how will we know they have learned it?
When teachers do have opportunities to share their work with each other, we encourage you to use ELP’s principles of High Quality Performance Assessment (HQPA) as a common language for exchanging feedback. We offer both a set of look-fors and single-point rubrics for each of the five principles. Don’t hesitate to reach out to us with questions on how to use these tools in your learning community.
with respect and gratitude for the work of educators everywhere.
This is an interactive hands-on workshop where participants will prototype a high quality performance assessment (HQPA) aligned to deeper learning competencies. Through learning stations, participants will explore the what and why of performance assessments and use quality criteria tools to analyze for rigor, learner agency, and authenticity. Participants will then prototype their ideal HQPA and brainstorm the potential implications on their school structures and pedagogies. The design experience will culminate with participants sharing their performance assessment tasks, identifying next first steps, and reflecting on their own learning and leadership.
Join us to…
- explore HQPA in relation to the design of a single task/challenge
- prototype or refine a task/challenge that aligns to HQPA and is designed so our most marginalized students can thrive

I am writing to share the news that December 30th marked my final day at Envision Learning Partners. It is impossible to put into words the depth of gratitude and appreciation I have for Envision as an organization, and for all of the amazing humans whom I have met over the past fifteen years(!!!!) – inside and outside of the org. Having spent the last decade and a half learning how to be an educator committed to deeper learning, and learning how to engage in transformative systems change work, there is no way that I can capture the role that Envision has played in my professional and personal evolution.
What did you most enjoy about being a coach with ELP?

I had no idea the profound impact that ELP would have on my life when I said yes to the opportunity to help found the organization and dream up what we wanted to do and be back in 2010. As I look back now, over a decade later, it is… of course… the people who have taught me the most, and whom I hold in my heart as I make my way through the world. Courageous and visionary school leaders from Hawaii to Maine who have invited me in to their most sacred place – their schools. Boundlessly passionate educators who have pushed their own practice with open hearts and open minds in order better support their most sacred people – their students. Brilliant partners who are doing the work in organizations across the country, confronting a complex and entrenched system that we all know can and needs to be better. And the ELP team… oh, the humans who are ELP… I have been held, challenged, taught, supported, encouraged, questioned, and loved by these humans in the most foundational of ways. So it feels quite impossible to describe what I have enjoyed the most about being a coach with ELP because it has been my identity for so long. The enjoyment is just one dimension of all that ELP has added to my life. Mostly, it has been all of you… so, thank you.

Why am I leaving and what am I doing next
It has been a deeply moving decision to say goodbye to these people and this place, and say yes to the unknown. But I feel called to set out on a new challenge, and to see where it takes me. As 2020 unfolded and the world was newly turned upside down because of covid, the persistent and inexcusable murders of unarmed Black men and women, forest fires raging around us, and clear threats to our democracy, I found myself heavy with so many questions of what am I doing? and what can I do? While I don’t feel that I have any definitive answers to those questions at this point, the process has led me to some new lenses of purpose and focus.

I am excited to announce that I have started my own consulting business called Core Shifts (website coming soon). I believe deeply in the power of performance assessment, and will continue to partner with schools and districts to support the work of building systems organized around the skills that young people need in order to go out into the world and create the lives in which they will thrive. I am excited to continue to partner with ELP in this work so that all students can experience the power of owning their own story of learning and growth. Simultaneously, I feel compelled to continue to confront and grapple with the ways in which my identity as a white woman within education has contributed, and still contributes to the oppression of marginalized students and adults. I am committed to doing the ongoing mirror work myself so that I can better explicitly name, analyze, and be an effective co-conspirator in working to reduce and ultimately dismantle the hold that white supremacy culture has on public education. (One way I have been practicing this internal work is through the co-design and co-facilitation of an anti-racist learning experience for white folks in affinity space with another former Envisioner. It is called What is at Your Core and you can learn more about that on the website. Our next course starts this month, if you know of anyone who might be interested).

It is at the explicit intersection of system redesign and anti-racist work that I hope to build Core Shifts. I have a lot to learn, and I am ready to lean into the challenge.
There are no words to capture how much of who I am now is because of my time at Envision Education, and Envision Learning Partners. I continue to be deeply inspired by the passion, the commitment, the vulnerability, and the care with which this organization and all of the incredible clients and partners with whom we work take on the unthinkably complex job of holding our young people at the center of all that we do… especially this year. Please know how grateful I am to have learned with you.

You can find me at abby@core-shifts.com.
Events
ELP continues to have a strong presence at conferences all over the US in 19-20:
- EdLeader21 conference last month in Houston, Texas. Our Executive Director, Justin Wells, facilitated a breakout session (with a district team from Springfield, MO) called Portrait to Performance with Portfolios.
- iNACOL, also last month, in Palm Springs, California. Our Deeper Learning Coach, Abby Benedetto, delivered the latest version of ELP’s Grad Profile 101 workshop.
Upcoming conferences:
- Assessment for Learning (February 2020) in San Diego, California, mentioned in this newsletter’s ED message. For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. ELP will be hosting workshops throughout the conference focused on Student Exhibitions & Defense of Learning.
Announcements
NEW ELP PARTNERS FOR 19-20
Each school year, ELP welcomes new education partners from across the country. Please join us in welcoming:
- East Palo Alto Academy: ELP will be working with EPAA to synthesize a clear vision for their graduates and build teacher capacity to integrate projects with rigorous assessments of content standards and transferable skills.
- Cleveland Metro Schools: ELP will be partnering with John Adams College & Career Academy to design a system of performance assessments that are aligned with their vision of a graduate and lead the graduating class of 2022 through Portfolio Defenses.
- Davis Joint Unified School District: ELP will be prototyping “defense of learning” systems aligned to the Davis USD Graduate Profile and accelerating the implementation of these systems among a cohort of piloting schools in the district.
- Fairfax County Public Schools: ELP will be assisting this innovative district with their student presentations of learning, providing feedback and an outside perspective.
- Purdue Polytechnic High School: ELP will build on the strengths at Purdue to align a cohesive performance assessment system, culminating in a capstone portfolio and defense.
- IL State Board of Ed: ELP worked with ISBE to identify and implement a project around needed resources, guidance, and support for Illinois to best understand how to provide competency-based education, performance-based assessment, and establish a shared culture of innovation to promote equity for all students. (This represents an opportunity for Illinois-based school districts, so please reach out to learn more.)
GATES FOUNDATION PROFESSIONAL LEARNING PARTNERSHIP GRANT
We are delighted to share that ConnectED and Envision Learning Partners are partnering with the San Diego Unified School District to enhance the integrated sequence of the Illustrative Mathematics high school curriculum. This work is funded by a grant from the Gates Foundation. In collaboration with our partners, we will leverage existing curriculum-embedded instructional resources and parent engagement approaches, elevating strategies that close achievement gaps for English Learners.
The Assessment for Learning Conference 2021
ELP is pleased to partner again with the Center for Innovation in Education and Next Generation Learning Challenges on the 2021 Assessment for Learning Conference!
The guiding question for AFL 2021 is: How will the assessment for learning movement lead us through the crises of the moment to a more just, equitable and student-centered future of learning?
AFL 2021 blurs the line between conference and community of practice. Think of it as a series of missions to escape the gravitational pull of our assumptions and to-do lists, so that we can find space for sharing, reflecting, connecting and imagining.
Get a head start on AFL 2021 right now! Join one of the free 75-minute virtual sessions to cut through the space junk, surface challenges and opportunities, share resources, and help us set the priorities for AFL 2021!
The National Geographic Society
ELP had the pleasure of leading the National Geographic Society and members of their global community through a Design Sprint. In facilitating a Liberatory Design Process, the team was able to develop a set of design principles that will be the foundation for future work and a lens with which to understand and refine past work.
DLLF: Where are they now?
We’re highlighting some of the DLLF alumni who are making moves- achieving goals, serving their communities, and impacting the future of education. Click here to read more about some of their achievements.
ELP has worked with 58 educational leaders from all over the United States since 2016 and we’re excited to open applications for our fifth cohort early next year!
Join us TOMORROW in the ELP Lounge!
The ELP Lounge will offer time to share stories, thought partnership with peers, or just the chance to throw up your hands and say, am I the only one experiencing this??? Plan to stop in and slow down to connect, share, learn, & heal. We can’t wait to see you.
Thursday, November 18th, 4:00-5:00pm PT (7:00-8:00pm ET)
Click here to grab your free ticket!
Deeper Learning Conference 2022
Share space with change-makers like you who are in search of a collective experience to highlight current triumphs and challenges, leverage student voice, and move from aspiration to action.Happening in-person and virtually, March 29th-31st, 2021. Get your tickets here.
More details about ELP’s sessions to come!
Envision Learning Partners is delighted and honored to introduce Alliance College-Ready Public Schools. ELP and Alliance kicked off our partnership in the 2018-19 school year. In our first year we worked together to deeply engage around building Alliance’s Graduate Profile (shown below). In 2019-20, we have been engaged with the Alliance team to develop a vertical articulation of the graduate profile.
Fifteen years ago a group of Los Angeles educators, civil rights activists, and community leaders believed in great public schools. They believed all kids could learn, regardless of zip code or background. They believed they could make a difference––and they did. Together, they founded Alliance College-Ready Public Schools to challenge the status quo for public education.
Today, 95% of Alliance seniors graduate high school and are accepted to college; 73% to a four-year college or university. In comparison, when Alliance opened its first public charter school in 2004 at the corner of Western and Martin Luther King Boulevard, the high school graduation rate in Los Angeles was 49%––many Los Angeles high schools were known as drop-out factories.
Eva Luc is the Director of Strategic Initiatives and College Success at Alliance and has shared her thoughts on our work together below.
Alliance Design Team working at a Vertical Alignment Workshop
What have you learnt during this process?
It’s critical to authentically engage the communities we serve and the staff on the ground, because they are ultimately the ones impacted by and carrying out the work, and they deserve to be front and center in the process. Otherwise, you risk creating for and not with folks. We are proud that school leaders, teachers, counselors, parent specialists, families, and scholars past and present co-created the Alliance Graduate Profile, and are also part of the vertical articulation and design teams.
Based on our scholars’ experiences, research and best practices, we know that academic strength is just part of what makes a successful Alliance graduate in whatever their chosen path beyond high school might be. The Graduate Profile provides a north star of the full set of skills (beyond just the academics) that we, as a network, should be focusing on. It allows us to have a cohesive vision of scholar success that we work towards collectively.
Is there one story you can share that illustrates how this work is benefitting your school and your students?
So far, the Graduate Profile has already impacted Alliance scholars in a positive way. Our Graduate Profile emphasized social and emotional learning so much so that Alliance created a new team – Scholar, Family and Community Services – this year to develop a framework for Social Emotional Learning and align resources to support that framework.
Read more about our partnership with Alliance in our January Guest Blog, written by Deeper Learning Coach, Morgan Vien.




































