Blogs

Checkout our most recent Resource Corner!

We're excited to share the culmination of a two-year research project, Pursuing Equity for Black & Latine Students with Learning Differences, which documents and illustrates the systems, practices, cultures, and supports that are associated with the well being and success of Black and Latine students with learning differences – students with disabilities and multilingual students with disabilities.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

We are honored to introduce Michelle Molitor, Executive Director of The Equity Lab.  Their equity work began as a response to the urgent need for culturally responsive systemic change for our most vulnerable students. Ms. Molitor has partnered with and led work alongside several national and regional education agencies and works directly with organizations across the education ecosystem, including the Department of Education, philanthropic groups, district offices, schools, and education-facing nonprofits. Michelle wrote this piece in partnership with Nicole Young.

The Kids Are Not Alright… Michelle Molitor and Nicole Young

Even the kids are feeling it. 

You can see it in the weary, glazed-over looks of your friends’ children on Instagram. Or in the hilarious quotes parents post about homeschooling on Twitter. Children, too, are tired of sitting in the house each day looking at their siblings, learning from their parents and their disembodied electronic teachers, and being unable to see their friends.

A friend recently posted about her four-year-old’s utter meltdown when she bombed their house for ants. He was devastated that she’d destroyed the only friends who had come to visit in weeks.

We’ve talked a lot about mental health during this pandemic, but we are often talking about adults. Kids, we assume, are resilient and much more adaptable than ourselves; we’ve decided they will be just fine. But children are feeling the same immeasurable strain adults are. 

We are communal mammals, and our brains are not designed for social isolation. It’s difficult to parse the cascading grief we’re feeling at the loss of loved ones, time with friends, activities we enjoy, or income — even as adults. How much more onerous must it be for children, who face the same realities with less insight into what is causing them? 

Some of the most accessible and cost effective mental health options for children in America are delivered through our schools. And when schools shut down, a lifeline for children in desperate need of counseling and support all but collapses. 

In the COVID-19 world, we need to think differently about how we provide for the whole child. As traditional schooling changes, it is imperative that we consider how to support children with trauma, kids whose homes may not be safe, and queer and trans kids navigating their identities in hostile environments. 

When we assume children are fine, that they are in less need of mental or spiritual support than ourselves, we are tacitly asking them to sublimate a portion of who they are. In doing so, we limit their complexity, ignore their needs, and most alarmingly, ask them to flatten themselves so that we can believe they are all right. 

Grounding in History

There is a violent legacy of assimilation in American schooling. Throughout our nation’s history, the most vulnerable students have been rounded up, tracked, beaten, and punished for being who they are.

In 1824, then Secretary of War John C. Calhoun created the Bureau of Indian Affairs, an office in the U.S. Department of the Interior that was tasked with “civilizing” and controlling Indigenous and Native American tribes across the country. 

In addition to forced displacement and brutal subjugation, the Bureau of Indian Affairs also oversaw the creation of “Indian boarding schools.” These schools, which operated for more than 100 years (from 1860 to 1978), were specifically designed to force the assimilation of Indian children to white culture and the English language. 

Indigenous children were taken from their homes, often without their parents’ consent, and sent to live in these boarding schools. Their hair was cut and their clothes were burned, they were beaten for using their native languages, they were often abused by their caretakers, they were forced to practice Christianity, and their cultural and familial ties were severed. 

In 1892, Richard H. Pratt, the man who established the Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania, famously delivered his “Kill the Indian, and Save the Man” speech. Indians were, in Pratt’s opinion, only worth saving if they could be Americanized. Every part of their Indian identity and culture was savagery that must be stripped away. His was the prevailing thought driving American policy and law through the turn of the 20th century and until the Indian Child Welfare Act was passed into federal law in 1978. 

Even as John Dewey’s research was leading a national discussion about educating the whole child, Indigenous and Native American children were enduring an educational system that viewed their cultural identity as a scourge to be erased. 

Listening to Those Most Impacted

By 1978, generations of Indigenous children had been forcibly assimilated through schools. In their own chilling accounts, survivors of this trauma recount the voicelessness that permeated their experience; they were unable to speak their own native tongues and unable to voice dissent in the language that was forced upon them. 

Are we listening to our students when they tell us what they need today? As children fight to stay engaged on laptops all day or dissolve into tears over dead ants, do we hear them? 

A global pandemic, we’re learning, affects everyone — in ways large and small. And instead of insisting children put on a bright face in the midst of such global uncertainty, it is incumbent upon us as educators, parents, and community members to ask them what they need to feel supported.  
For children who are struggling in homes where their identities are under attack, this is even more important. How do we make room in our thinking, and eventually in our policy making, to prioritize the voices of LGTBQ students, students facing abuse, or those struggling with trauma and depression? 

COVID-19 has cracked wide open the deficiencies in our education system. But as we reconfigure the system to support adult needs, are we listening to young people? 

Advocate for Radical Change

We see echoes of the Indian boarding schools’ philosophies in our classrooms and schools today. Students are asked to leave their identities at the school door. Black, Latinx, poor, and immigrant parents are seen as nuisances rather than co-designers in their children’s education. 

However, students do not come to school as empty vessels waiting to be filled. Instead, they come full of incredible strengths and their own individual stories. To make radical change in this area would be to create an education system that encourages children to lean into their identities and genius, rather than stifling them for adult comfort. 

We will only see a radical shift in American education when we begin to devalue compliance and assimilation. As much as children need structure, they also deserve an education that is compassionate and treats them as the whole people they are. 

If we reimagine an educational system that serves the whole child, parents, families, students, and educators must be equal partners in defining its purpose and leading its design. For vulnerable students, those facing abuse or those whose families would punish them for being LGBTQ, a holistic model must address the realities they face when they get home. 

Ultimately, radical change means investing in the whole child being able to heal and thrive. 

Build and Iterate

Assimilation is a tool, wielded by a racist, homophobic, sexist, and capitalist society to quell difference. Its dominance in our education system means that we are stifling children and actively ignoring their needs as physical, mental, and spiritual beings. But if such an oppressive system is designed, it can be redesigned. 

This requires recreating an education system with the needs of the most marginalized children at the center. This necessitates adults mobilizing in support of children — not on their behalf. And it demands a different orientation to the many facets of childhood in a rapidly changing world. 

Want to Learn More? 

Watch Unseen Tears: The Native American Boarding School Experience in Western New York

OR 

Read Moving Equity Work Toward Action in the Age of Covid-19

Envision Learning Partners is delighted and honored to introduce the Colorado Education Initiative (CEI). The Colorado Education Initiative is a statewide nonprofit organization in Colorado that invests time, expertise, and dollars in schools, students, educators, and leaders. They are rooted in a vision of equitable outcomes for every kid that drives a strong bias for action focused on sustainable change to the system. 

ELP and CEI kicked off our partnership in the 2017-18 school year. Amy Spicer is the Senior Program Lead at CEI and has shared her thoughts on our work together below.

How are you redesigning and advancing your systems to provide rigorous and equitable capstone experiences for your students?

We have been working with ELP for the past two years to help schools and districts in Colorado build capstone experiences that meet the needs of our state’s Graduation Guidelines policy.  Graduation Guidelines put a menu in place for districts to use in establishing graduation requirements, including traditional ways to demonstrate college and career readiness such as SAT and ACT scores, as well as performance-based demonstrations such as portfolios and capstone projects.

The capstone and performance assessment options both open up immense possibilities for Colorado’s students. In addition to providing students with more options to show that they have mastered academic content, the performance-based pathways to graduation allow students to go beyond demonstrating proficiency in traditional academic subjects. The world is rapidly changing, and what students need to be successful in college, a career, and in life require additional skills like collaboration, critical thinking, creativity, and problem-solving—all things that students cannot show with a single test score.

CEI’s partnership with ELP has resulted in over fifteen schools and districts building systems that are equally rigorous to test scores and have allowed Colorado districts to rethink assessment practices in ways that are more inclusive and empowering of students who have been under-served by our traditional systems. When done well, capstones can show more of what students know and are able to do than the SAT or ACT.

How have performance assessment principles, tools, frameworks, examples, and/or best practices, informed this work?

Our work has benefited greatly from the guidance from ELP. The theory of action that ELP brings—define a graduate profile, design a system of performance assessments that measure that profile, and implement pedagogies and school structures that lead to success—has allowed for schools and districts to create comprehensive capstone systems that break through traditional learning environments. In particular, we have seen the immense impact that the locally-developed graduate profile has on building rigorous capstones. When communities come together to define the competencies and skills they seek for their students to acquire in their K-12 career, they have a framework in which to design systems and structures that allow students to demonstrate their mastery.

What have you learned during this process? What has been the impact of this work ON YOU? Is there one story you can share that illustrates this?

I have learned so much through this project and our partnership with Envision. By far the biggest impact on me has been on how I approach supporting schools and districts to enact change: when the work is meaningful and relevant, we as facilitators need to introduce tools and resources and then get out of the way.  When we first started this project, there was one school district in particular that asked to have a lot of interrupted time to work on their capstone after our initial kickoff and introduction. At first, we weren’t sure how this would go—would they create rigorous plans? Would they make the amount of progress we were seeking? Could we let go and see what happened?

This district—Canon City School District—ended up making a significant amount of progress in a short time. They have created an incredible program that is based on the needs of their community, one that has become an exemplar across the state. What they are building is still a work in progress, but they have taught me the value of not over-facilitating and trusting in the good work that our educators—who are truly the experts—accomplish when they are given inspiration, time, and space. This has impacted my work far beyond the scope of this project, as I have taken this lesson into all projects I lead.

Click here for a deeper look into CEI’s Capstone Design.

Follow CEI on Twitter!

The “yes buts”—the common objections to performance assessment—keep dropping away.

The latest comes with the revolutionary announcement from the UC Board of Regents last week: Going forward, the SAT or ACT test is not required for admission to a UC campus. The requirement will be phased out completely by 2025.

And just like that, there goes the “yes but the SAT” counterargument to performance assessment system building. An institutional practice that had seemed entrenched is now revealed by the pandemic to be fragile.

We can add the SAT to a growing list that includes “Yes but instructional minutes,” “Yes but the end-of-year standardized tests,” and “Yes but the course grade.”

Meanwhile, the concept of a defense of learning has proven resilient in this crisis. ELP is proud to partner with the Learning Policy Institute and the Linked Learning Alliance to launch the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series, which in coming weeks presents multiple opportunities to observe students’ virtual defenses of learning and engage in conversations with the inspiring students and educators who have remained committed to performance assessment despite school closures. (For those of you wondering about ELP’s long running practice of Defense Design Studios, this series is where we are putting that energy this year.)

Watch this web page closely for upcoming dates associated with the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series. There are some events happening later this week. And more will be added as plans get solidified. Students and schools are moving fast. Don’t take it from us: Watch Envision student Dani Martin vlog about preparing for her virtual defense.   I can’t wait to witness what students have to say about their learning in the next couple weeks, and to discuss the implications of this with all of you in the months to come.

Stay safe,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

DEFENSE DESIGN STUDIO UPDATE

ELP will be moving our annual Defense Design Studio energy to sharing stories in the hopes of inspiring others to take on the powerful practice of student defenses of learning. We have partnered up with the Learning Policy Institute and the Linked Learning Alliance as part of the California Performance Assessment Collaborative to bring you an online series of virtual defenses and behind-the-scene interviews.

Take a look at the first video in the series, Envision senior, Dani Martin, who vlogs about preparing for her virtual defense.

Click here for more information, including how you can get involved!!

ELP HAS OFFICIALLY LAUNCHED OUR NEW PODCAST, ReMix-Ed!

This podcast situates where Assessment, Deeper Learning, Equity and Systems Change meet. Transforming schools is not light work. We illuminate complexities, lift up what’s working and imagine a path forward. With our equity lens we seek to learn from marginalized identities AND intentionally lift up their expertise.

Use this link to check out the first three episodes.

TWITTER CHAT: DEFENDING LEARNING IN MATH

ELP just held our second Twitter Chat earlier this month and the focus was all about students defending their learning in math. The online conversation was held by our Director of STEM, Vinci Daro and previous Deeper Learning Coach & math enthusiast, Jim Malamut.

Keep an eye out for our next Twitter Chat by following ELP on Twitter at @EnvisionSchools and using the hashtag #ELPCoachChat!

Click here to see the resources from our first chat, held in March, which focused on Developing & Measuring your Grad Profile with Deeper Learning Coaches, Abby Benedetto & Suzanne Malek.

A Note from the Designers: Just so you know- we hear you and we are answering your call!

Path Pace Tool

“Yes – we want to lean in and invite students to tell the journey of their learning in a Virtual Defense… but where do we start?”

We are thrilled that you are digging deeper into the Virtual Defense Toolkit! Each part of this Toolkit is being built with our own main design principle in mind: Tight on criteria, loose on path. Thus the Path Pace is intended to be a guide as you look at where you are currently, and how you might move as a system toward virtual student defenses and beyond.This tool includes suggested tasks and timelines for each of the primary stakeholder groups – students, advisors/mentors, and Admin. We then break down those tasks into week-long chunks. We invite you to explore this tool and then reflect on your context, your capacity, and what feels right for your community. Adopt what resonates, adapt what you want to modify, and hopefully this gives you a place to start. We will be offering resources for several of these tasks as the days go on, and are excited to continue to build what you may need as you take this on.

Student Planning Tool

“This is awesome… but how do we support students to hold parts of this process?” 

Yes! We are so glad you asked. Any student-centered assessment supports students to be co- designers of the experience and invites them to activate their agency in the process. This planning tool is built to help them set goals, track key information, manage workload and consider important factors as they prepare to defend their learning.In this new landscape, we know that circumstances and home learning contexts are unique to each student. As you engage in building towards a culminating event with your students, we invite you to question assumptions and let students lead where possible. They are the experts in their home contexts and can make choices about how and when to complete work, the best space in their home environments for hosting the event and of course- how to best be their authentic selves in this process.As always, these tools are an offering and we are excited to see how you use them and what other needs emerge. We are actively designing and releasing this package as needs become clear.Onward!We held a couple of sessions to answer questions and dream with you all. We were excited to learn more about the complexities you’re working through and to imagine how we can support.

Virtual Portfolio Defense Webinar: Tuesday, April 14th

  • This webinar was recorded and is available using this link.

Virtual Defense: Ask Me Anything Session: Thursday, April 16th

  • Stay tuned for details from the session!

Join the conversation on Twitter by tagging us @EnvisionSchools and using the hashtag #ELPVirtualDefense.

Stay Well,

Morgan Vien & Abby Benedetto, ELP Deeper Learning Coaches

Click here to download these tools and more!

Still hot from the forgery, ELP’s Virtual Portfolio Defense Toolkit is hereby released to the world. Click the button below to download the toolkit. Use it and share it widely. We hope that it inspires action, saves you time, and helps you find opportunity within this crisis to put students at the center of their learning.

ELP was galvanized by what we are hearing from our partner schools and districts: Rather than backing off from your performance assessment systems, most of you are leaning into them, understanding that students need this now more than ever. This toolkit is ELP’s first answer to your call for help. It is designed for learning communities at all levels of experience, whether you’ve had kids defending their learning for years or see this as your first opportunity to try.

Prototype Level 1: Reflective Presentation

Prototype Level 2: Virtual Defense of Learning

Prototype Level 3: ‘Live Stream’ Rite of Passage

We are excited to populate this section with all of the amazing things you envision and create. Take inspiration from some of the folks who have been innovating and reimagining how to do their work in the time of COVID-19.

Virtual Portfolio Defense Toolkit

Click the images below for more information on these tools and download them for free!

         

Student VLOG: Virtual Defenses of Learning

Now that Defenses have become virtual, what has changed with how you feel about Defenses, and how you are approaching Defenses? What is hard about that change? What is exciting about that change?

In this first in a series of vlogs we are releasing, a high school senior talks about how she is adapting her defense for a virtual space and how she is feeling about it.

Still hot from the forge, ELP’s Virtual Portfolio Defense Toolkit is hereby released to the world. Click the button below to download the toolkit. Use it and share it widely. We hope that it inspires action, saves you time, and helps you find opportunity within this crisis to put students at the center of their learning.

ELP was galvanized by what we are hearing from our partner schools and districts: Rather than backing off from your performance assessment systems, most of you are leaning into them, understanding that students need this now more than ever. This toolkit is ELP’s first answer to your call for help. It is designed for learning communities at all levels of experience, whether you’ve had kids defending their learning for years or see this as your first opportunity to try.

And know that there are more tools on the way. Before the end of the week, we’ll release an accompanying Student Planning Tool, a student-facing organizer to help them plan for their virtual defenses or presentations. (Update: these tools have been released and are available using the link below.)

Next week, Morgan Vien and Abby Benedetto, chief designers of this toolkit, will host a webinar and some virtual office hours so that you can ask questions and get support for implementation. (Update: use the link below to view the webinar recording.)

There is no better time than now to challenge and honor young people with an opportunity to tell the story of their learning.

Cheering you on,

Justin Wells & the ELP Team

Click here to download this tool and more!

Abby- A0: One way to check the quality of your graduate profile is to use the ELP Quality Criteria Tool that asks a series of questions to guide your revision process. LINKED HERE!

Suzanne- A0: In my experience so far, there are three key things that make a graduate profile good. It has to reflect skills that needed in many areas of life. It has to be actionable and measurable. And it has to be attractive and accessible to students and stakeholders.

Abby– A0: A great way to check the “Authenticity” is to pull up a current job description from any industry and see how many of your graduate profile skills show up in what businesses are looking for in employees. Fun to have students and adults do this!

Suzanne- A1: Taking a graduate profile from a poster on the wall to an organizing principle of a school means first taking the “Headlines” of the skills and breaking them down into observable outcomes. Once you have involved your community in naming the observable behaviors all students must be able to demonstrate in order to graduate, you can design or redesign your assessment system to support all learners in developing and demonstrating those skills. Once you have some great assessments in place, a reflective school staff and leadership can analyze their whole system through the lens of what kind of culture, structures, other elements, are needed to prepare all students to be successful in those assessments.

Abby- A1: You cannot measure a graduate profile with a fill-in-the-blanks quiz. More authentic demonstrations of learning like portfolio defense, student-led conferences, capstone projects, etc. are necessary to challenge students to demonstrate their skills.

Suzanne- A2: At @BryanAdamsHS a public school in Dallas they designed Portfolio Defenses to measure their Portrait of a Graduate. All their students do 2 before they graduate. 1 big shift was developing advisory to support all students. Ask @MaryAnnSuhl. (MaryAnn is a Coordinator for Dallas ISD and was a teacher leader and then key system re-designer and Coordinator at Bryan Adams)

Read more about our partnership with Bryan Adams here.

Abby- A2: A hugely impactful shift is that a system must make room for reflection when actualizing a graduate profile. Regular moments to pause and make deep connections between the grad profile skills and the work of school and life is a powerful necessity for all.

Abby- A3: As with all good teaching, you want to begin with the end in mind. We think about the process as 3 steps, our Theory of Action. It is vital to involve ALL stakeholder groups every step of the way, especially those most marginalized in your system.We encourage you to assemble diverse co-creators that represent all of the voices in your system: students, families, teachers, community members, higher education, etc. to begin an inquiry process about your definition of success for your young people, and what skills are needed.

Suzanne- A4: The BIGGEST pitfall is doing nothing. Use design thinking: build on your strengths & start actualizing your Graduate Profile today! You have to prototype, test, reflect, revise, and improve, or it will forever remain an abstract idea.

Make sure to follow ELP on Twitter @EnvisionSchools and use the hashtag #ELPCoachChat to join our next Twitter Chat!

Over the course of our year as Nexus Fellows (see the I am ELP post: Nexus Edition for more insight) we were given many incredible resources to guide and help us in our journey to design a better, more equitable education system for all children. Our Nexus journey was captured beautifully by Caroline Hill (228 Accelerator and Nexus Coach). Follow them on Twitter at @228accelerator.

During the 2019 calendar year, ELP’s Alcine Mumby and Aragon Burlingham participated in the first Nexus Fellowship, a program from the Equity Lab. Nexus was designed in response to the overwhelming need for race, equity, diversity, and inclusion (REDI) in the learning profession.

This was a transformative experience for us and the other 14 Nexus Fellows! Michelle and her talented team curated a deep and personal experience for our new community of equity leaders. Nexus took us into a deep personalized leadership journey based on our identities around three specific design challenges:  challenges with people, challenges with processes, and challenges with programs.

Watch the video to hear about the experiences of the Nexus Fellows and Equity Lab’s ED, Michelle Molitor.

Thank you Michelle and your exceptional team for creating this incredible program!

Reflections on the Assessment for Learning Conference by Morgan Vien, Contributing Conference Designer

The AfL Conference was a powerful experience for me in many ways. A huge part of my job is curating learning experiences that shake up “business as usual.”  In a conference design role, it was interesting to design an experience for 400 people that felt personal, reflective and inclusive. That being said, I think we did that. I am stoked to continue to build out this muscle and imagine what is possible for this gathering. One shift I would make for the future is to support presenters to design even more hands on learning experiences for participants. As leaders who believe in learner-centered processes, we have to practice what we preach and this conference experience is a great place to prototype that work across contexts.

Stay tuned for AfL Conference 2021, as well as resources from this year’s conference!

Cancellation of Deeper Learning Conference 2020

In light of the current health climate, the difficult decision to cancel Deeper Learning 2020 was made. The event will not be rescheduled to later on this year, instead all efforts will be put toward making DL2021 an epic event, set for March 23-25, 2021! The Envision Learning Partners look forward to connecting with everyone in San Diego next year!

Registration will open in September. For more information, click here.

As you work furiously and heroically to serve your students through the COVID-19 crisis, ELP offers this advice: Don’t forget about your graduate profile. Now’s the time to lean into it.

It doesn’t matter whether your performance assessment system is well established or just getting off the ground, whether you’re currently reaching your students through Zoom or printed worksheet packets. If your learning community has a graduate profile or similar set of learner outcomes, you should use that language to remind your students of their assets and to challenge them to grow. Most graduate profiles were designed to focus us on the skills students need to navigate a fast-changing world with an unpredictable future. Now we get to put them to the test.

Many graduate or learner profiles, for example, target a competency that has to do with being a “self-directed learner.” Let’s admit that it’s a concept more aspirational than operational. In most of our highly-structured learning environments, young people have very little opportunity to practice being self-directed. Guess what? Now they need it. And we need to teach it. So invoke the skill, express high expectations for students to develop the skill during this time, give them ideas for how to practice and demonstrate it, structure opportunities for them to reflect on it, and challenge them to document evidence of their growth. This goes for any skill that’s on your graduate profile.

Stay tuned. In coming weeks, ELP will continue to share suggestions for ways to leverage or advance the elements of your performance assessment system: the use of portfolios, running defenses of learning virtually, building a culture of revision and reflection. There are enormous opportunities in this crisis for students to practice and be assessed on the skills we say are important.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

We understand these are challenging times for many people, especially educators challenged with rapid transition to online teaching. Here are some resources we’ve been gathering to potentially help:

free-online-courses-300x211-1.png

Keep an eye out for more resources and if you aren’t already signed up for our bi-monthly newsletter, sign up here. This will deliver updates, interesting news, and resources right to your inbox!

Dear ELP Partner,In this time of crisis, I am reminded of one of ELP’s defining characteristics of a high-quality performance assessment: it is tight on quality criteria while open to different learner approaches.

That principle certainly applies to our relationship with you in the uncertain times ahead. Now more than ever, ELP is committed to supporting your school system and finding creative ways to help you navigate the crisis while still moving toward your goals. We take seriously our role as your partner, so as you face the challenges posed by the coronavirus, consider us part of your support team.

Your ELP coach will be reaching out, if they haven’t already, to extend that support, offer thought partnership, and think through shifts that may need to happen in our service to you. ELP takes pride in being nimble and flexible in our service to partners. And there are opportunities that emerge in any crisis: more time for some virtual PD with teachers, for example, if students are at home doing lessons online.

With deep empathy for leaders of schools and districts (our own Envision Schools are closing on Monday, March 16th),

Justin Wells | Executive Director

Click here for a list of resources. More to come!

Is your Grad Profile made up of complex cognitive skills, not values? That’s one of the 10+ questions we ask with our Graduate Profile Quality Criteria Check Tool. We have been delighted to see the surge in Graduate Profiles developed by school systems across the USA over the past year but have noticed the need for an important next step: check whether your new grad profile meets these important quality criteria that we’ve developed over the past decade working with hundreds of schools.

Click the resource button to download the PDF.

Morgan Vien writes about ELP’s work with Alliance College-Ready Public Schools

ELP and Alliance kicked off our partnership in the 2018-19 school year. In our first year we worked together to deeply engage around building a graduate profile. In 2019-20, we have been engaged with the Alliance team to develop a vertical articulation of the graduate profile with the intention of using that vertical articulation as a tool for a few things:

  1. Make the graduate profile accessible across all grade levels and contexts for instruction and whole student support, and to be able to align their model, too.
  2. Use it as a way to continue to engage their stakeholders and to scale their graduate profile work.

What are some of the enabling conditions that allow Alliance to be great partners with ELP?

  • Alliance leadership has had conversations about the power of a graduate profile and that it was born based on this movement to not only get kids into college but to ensure kids have the soft and hard skills to get through college as well. Because of that, there’s an established value set within the leadership, home office, principals and micro-communities of these hard and soft skills and desire to codify measures for all of those.
  • Alliance’s leadership in the Home Office have a deep sense of equity, high expectations for students, a clear expectation of that change management looks like on the leadership level, a deep respect for school leadership, and a real want to do it well and to get real buy-in. Finally, a real understanding that this work is complex, that it takes a human to hold the work and to orchestrate that and that they can truly have design teams doing the work and have teachers being the faces of this work.
  • Thoughtful, intentional choices around how to roll out the work, who does it and a clear value in the resources behind the movement for their graduate profile.
  • The Alliance team is really committed to what they do, and are also coachable – tight on criteria and loose on pathway.
  • Alliance has a dedicated person directly holding the work, tight attention to process and product, and collective ownership of the work.
  • Alliance has a strong culture for quality of engagement and quality of work leading to a commitment to being timely, thorough and intentional with what they are doing.

ELP Executive Director, Justin Wells, with the Alliance team.

ELP looks forward to our continued partnership with Alliance!

For more information about Alliance, click here to see their Partner Profile.

Although I have a title of Executive Director (privileged to do work I love with people who inspire me), I still call myself a teacher. I have always been, and remain, completely in thrall to the process of human learning.

Back in 2008, in my sixth year as an English teacher for Envision Schools, I was lucky to be involved in the design and implementation of a multi-disciplinary project that was chronicled by a professional documentarian. Many of you will be familiar with this video of the Campaign Ad Project, but for those who aren’t, it’s a blast-from-the-past glimpse into who I am as a teacher, why I love teaching in a deeper learning culture, and why I am so committed to the overlapping concepts of project-based learning and performance assessment.

Young people deserve learning experiences that are challenging, exciting, supportive, and memorable—what I like to call “learning you can tell a story about.” ELP’s mission is to help learning communities create the conditions for these kinds of experiences to be typical, not extraordinary.

Follow Justin on Twitter @jusowells.

This rounds out our introduction of every ELP team member. In upcoming installments, we’ll pose questions that prompt deeper insights into the ELP team. If you have a question for the team that you’d like answered, please send your question to Courtney Katen for a chance to have it answered in a future newsletter.

Welcome the Fourth Cohort of the Deeper Learning Leadership Forum!

We are delighted to announce the education leaders that have been selected to join the newest cohort of our Deeper Learning Leadership Forum. The Deeper Learning Leadership Forum (DLLF) is a cohort-based leadership experience that aims to develop, strengthen, and support a group of educational leaders to work at the intersection of equity and design thinking. As DLLF members cultivate relationships and learn across their diverse contexts, they will become more adept and strategic at leading reform efforts in their local systems, thus producing more equitable deeper learning outcomes across the country.

Meet our fourth cohort leaders here. Click the link and scroll down to Cohort 4!

Envision Education is hiring!

Envision Education is seeking a dynamic, experienced educator and leader to build on the successes of our three high schools and two middle schools and establish Envision Schools as exemplar schools of equity and excellence for our students and for Envision Learning Partners. The Chief Academic Officer (CAO) will do this by providing vision, management experience, educational expertise, and operational oversight. Click here for the official position description.

Questions? Contact David Edwards, Director of Talent and Human Resources – dedwards@envisionschools.org – 510.451.2415 x 107

IL-EMPOWER

ELP has been selected as an approved learning partner by IL-EMPOWER for Illinois schools. IL-EMPOWER is the statewide system of support that empowers schools with greater choice in determining their path to improved student outcomes.  Schools are informed through a continuous school improvement process which includes analysis of academic and school quality indicators, a system needs assessment, and selecting an approved learning partner like ELP.

To learn more about our partnership, click here.

How ELP Delivers Internal Professional Development!

ELP spends much of its time delivering PD to our partners from coast to coast. Many partners don’t realize that we also turn our PD chops inwards to refine our practices, learn from each other’s work in the field and have some fun along the way! At our last retreat, we focused our efforts on refining our definition of High Quality Performance Assessments. We believe a High Quality Performance Assessment…

  • elicits evidence of skills and knowledge that matter
  • is tight on quality criteria while open to different approaches
  • is authentic
  • is a learning experience in and of itself

We’ll expand on this suite of definitions in the coming weeks – stay tuned!

Happy Holidays from the ELP team!

UPCOMING CONFERENCES

The Assessment for Learning Conference is next month! Below is a sneak peak at the ELP-lead sessions!

  • Let Us Count the Ways: Creatively Tackling the Logistics of Exhibition – Suzanne Malek – Wednesday, February 12 • 9:15am – 10:15am
  • It’s Elementary, My Dear!: Exhibition at the Elementary Level – Morgan Vien & Jeff Embleton – Wednesday, February 12 • 10:40am – 12:10pm
  • Creating Culminating Assessments Where ALL Students Thrive – Abby Benedetto & Alcine Mumby – Wednesday, February 12 • 1:30pm – 3:00pm
  • Show Don’t Tell: How to Design Capstone Experiences that Embody Your Learning Outcomes – Justin Wells – Wednesday, February 12 • 1:30pm – 3:00pm
  • Taking a Defense Process from Good to Great using Quality Criteria – Abby Benedetto – Thursday, February 13 • 9:30am – 11:00am

 Join ELP for the following sessions at the Deeper Learning Conference on March 25-27, 2020 in San Diego, CA!

  • “Deeper Assessment: Designing Equitable Performance Assessment Systems” Deep Dive – Alcine Mumby & Abby Benedetto
  • “A Catalyzing Experience: Working In Alliance Across Difference” Den – Alcine Mumby, Morgan Vien, Rachel Maida, & Courtney Katen
  • “We are Change-makers: Working at the intersection of Equity and Design” Den – the Deeper Learning Leadership Forum, Cohort 3
  • “Preparing Students to Build their Future: Developing and Measuring Design Thinking Mindsets” Deep Dive – Ruth Chung Wei & the Design Tech High School
  • “Hacking + Holonomy = Hardware” Deep Dive – Morgan Vien & Jeff Embleton from ASCEND

DEFENSE DESIGN STUDIOS

Observe an entire Portfolio Defense, learn how the model works, and reflect on how you can apply the concepts in your own context.The Portfolio Defense is the capstone activity of a whole-school performance assessment system.  It is the culmination of a student’s 4-year journey. Similar to a masters defense, students stand before a panel of peers, educators, and mentors to demonstrate — to the panel and to themselves — that they are ready to graduate and ready for a successful future.A Defense Design Studio consists of two parts:

  1. Observe a live student defense: watch a student defend their learning in front of a panel.
  2. Debrief – Talk with an Envision Learning Partners coach and fellow educators about how to translate this nationally-recognized assessment model to your own educational context.

Join ELP at our partner school’s DDS:

  • Bryan Adams High School – Dallas, TX – March 26 & 27, 2020
  • LAUSD – Linked Learning – Los Angeles, CA
    • March 20 – School for the Visual Arts and Humanities
    • April 21 – Los Angeles High School of the Arts
    • June 1 – Nightingale Middle School

Bay Area Envision Education DDS dates TBD.

Envision Learning Partners is delighted and honored to introduce Alliance College-Ready Public Schools. ELP and Alliance kicked off our partnership in the 2018-19 school year. In our first year we worked together to deeply engage around building Alliance’s Graduate Profile (shown below). In 2019-20, we have been engaged with the Alliance team to develop a vertical articulation of the graduate profile.

Fifteen years ago a group of Los Angeles educators, civil rights activists, and community leaders believed in great public schools. They believed all kids could learn, regardless of zip code or background. They believed they could make a difference––and they did. Together, they founded Alliance College-Ready Public Schools to challenge the status quo for public education.

Today, 95% of Alliance seniors graduate high school and are accepted to college; 73% to a four-year college or university. In comparison, when Alliance opened its first public charter school in 2004 at the corner of Western and Martin Luther King Boulevard, the high school graduation rate in Los Angeles was 49%––many Los Angeles high schools were known as drop-out factories.

Eva Luc is the Director of Strategic Initiatives and College Success at Alliance and has shared her thoughts on our work together below.

Alliance Design Team working at a Vertical Alignment Workshop

What have you learnt during this process?

It’s critical to authentically engage the communities we serve and the staff on the ground, because they are ultimately the ones impacted by and carrying out the work, and they deserve to be front and center in the process. Otherwise, you risk creating for and not with folks. We are proud that school leaders, teachers, counselors, parent specialists, families, and scholars  past and present co-created the Alliance Graduate Profile, and are also part of the vertical articulation and design teams.

Based on our scholars’ experiences, research and best practices, we know that academic strength is just part of what makes a successful Alliance graduate in whatever their chosen path beyond high school might be. The Graduate Profile provides a north star of the full set of skills (beyond just the academics) that we, as a network, should be focusing on. It allows us to have a cohesive vision of scholar success that we work towards collectively.

Is there one story you can share that illustrates how this work is benefitting your school and your students?

So far, the Graduate Profile has already impacted Alliance scholars in a positive way. Our Graduate Profile emphasized social and emotional learning so much so that Alliance created a new team – Scholar, Family and Community Services – this year to develop a framework for Social Emotional Learning and align resources to support that framework.

Read more about our partnership with Alliance in our January Guest Blog, written by Deeper Learning Coach, Morgan Vien.

Measuring what Matters, Learning by Doing, and Piloting with Purpose

There is statewide support for Deeper Learning in Colorado, and Envision Learning Partners is playing a key role.

In 2007, the state of Colorado asked districts to choose the ways their students will demonstrate college and career readiness, and therefore readiness to graduate from high school.

This Graduation Guidelines menu lists the options. In the mix of more traditional tests, two options provide a clear pathway for students to graduate by demonstrating their skills through an individualized product or presentation: Capstone Projects and Collaboratively Developed Standards-Based Performance Assessment.

Coaching Deeper Learning in Colorado

Since April 2018, Envision Learning Partners has been honored and energized to work in an accelerated way with educators at every level of the Colorado educational system, to design meaningful and sustainable assessment systems worthy of and accessible to every student in Colorado, strongly aligned to the demands of a wide variety of 21st century college and career options.

This June marks the close of two incredible first-year partnerships between ELP and the Colorado Department of Education, as well as the Colorado Education Initiative; both projects involve educators from every corner of the state to transform education statewide.

  • Learn about the transformative work being done through the partnership between ELP and the Colorado Department of Education on Performance Assessment
  • Learn about the transformative work being done through the partnership between ELP and the Colorado Education Initiative on Capstone Projects

Transitions and Opportunities for Envision Learning Partners

Dear ELP Community:

I am writing with news about a transition for Envision Learning Partners. This past year has been eventful for us (as I am sure it has been for you). We onboarded a new Executive Director and a new Assessment Design Partner. We completed strategic plan processes for both Envision Learning Partners and Envision Education org-wide. We are about to finish a 3-month study of our impact and ways to expand it. Now, as we wrap up the school year, we consider the future and make decisions about how to navigate education’s changing times and shifting landscapes.

Royce Conner, ELP’s Executive Director, will be transitioning from his role on June 30th. We are grateful to Royce for the important contributions he has made and projects he has led during his tenure, and we deeply support him as he moves into the next chapter of his distinguished career as an educator. Feel free to connect with Royce on LinkedIn.

Royce’s responsibilities will be distributed across Envision Education as part of a comprehensive org-wide strategy to deepen the integration between our schools (our local impact) and our consulting service (our nationwide impact). Out in the field, our remarkable team of coaches and operations professionals will continue to help school districts build high-quality performance assessment systems. In my role as Chief Program Officer, I am excited for the opportunity and the commitment to make the sum of “One Envision” to be greater than its already powerful parts.

As we head into the summer, when educators often feel a welcome shift in pace, I invite you to reach out to me with questions or wonders. ELP remains your steadfast partner in our movement to bring high-quality performance assessment to all students.

In community,

Justin Wells, Chief Program Officer

In a recent conversation with fellow advocates of performance assessment, a colleague made the point that our job as educators is not to teach standards but to teach students.

Of course, standards play an important role in guiding teachers’ work. But given the structures and incentives of our system, it’s easy for standards to slip into the position of ends rather than means. Tragically, covering standards—“I taught it; some got it.”—feeds inequities that plague education. When we truly reorient to “teaching students,” we stay focused on those whole human beings in our classrooms. What do our students need to achieve, how will we know they have achieved it, and how do we support their getting there? This is performance assessment system design.

The graduate profile movement is a boon, pushing students into the focal point of our energies. Social-emotional learning (SEL) is trending, reminding us to attend to the whole child. But none of these ideas will translate into lived learning experiences until students are regularly tackling rigorous and real-world challenges that elicit the skills they need to practice and master. Our kids need high-quality performance assessments.

Join us on twitter for more conversation about the importance of teaching students over standards, using the hashtag #TeachStudentsNotStandards

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

During his keynote at last fall’s EdLeader21 Conference, educational thought leader, Tony Wagner, did not mince words. “A graduate portrait without an assessment,” he said, “is useless.”

The audience members—mainly district leaders from around the country—audibly shifted in their seats. Although it’s hard to disagree, it’s also hard to pull off. How can school districts assess skills that are as complex as the ones we see on a typical graduate profile?

Tony followed up his challenge with two recommendations:

  1. “Every student should have a digital portfolio.”
  2. “Every student should present or defend their learning.”

He’s right. Portfolio assessment and presentations of learning (which come in many forms, including defenses and student-led conferences) are two effective, customizable, scalable, and actionable ways to move from “poster to practice.”

ELP cheers the graduate profile movement because of its potential to change our society’s conception of education’s purpose. But we also worry for the movement. If we don’t see graduate profiles made visible in the actual work of our students—“show don’t tell,” says this old English teacher—then we’re destined to look back on this as another edu-trend that came to nothing. That’s why Tony Wagner’s admonition is so urgent.

The challenge of assessing graduate profiles is one of the major themes of next month’s Assessment for Learning Conference. I know I will see many of you there, and I am excited for the opportunity to work on this together.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

Justin Wells,

ELP Executive Director

ELP is thrilled to welcome Morgan Vien to our team of Deeper Learning Coaches. Fabulously talented and exploding with ideas, Morgan complements our team with her experience in K-8 school leadership (most recently, serving as principal at ASCEND School in Oakland) and facilitating design thinking (as a School Retool Coach for Stanford’s d.school). We, and our client partners, are going to learn so much from her. Please welcome Morgan when you see her out in the field.

In other ELP news, we recently hatched a new strategic plan, our first since joining forces with the Stanford Center for Assessment, Learning, and Equity (SCALE) over a year and a half ago. ELP’s vision—every student in America is learning within a high-quality performance assessment system—is ambitious in scale and generational in scope, so we know we need to set ourselves up for the long haul. In the coming three years, our strategic priorities are:

  • to grow our service to American public school districts, the primary agent of educational delivery in this country.
  • to expand the ways that we serve our client partners so that they have more pathways to success.
  • to ensure that equity is not only the reason for this work but also the process of how we do this work.
  • to catalyze research on the impact of high-quality performance assessment systems on student learning.
  • to establish the sustainability of our business model so that we can deliver on our mission indefinitely.

As always, we welcome your thought partnership. Let us know what you think about our plan, or ask any one of us to elaborate when our paths cross in the field.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

The COVID crisis deepens. All of us engaged in the endeavor of learning—students and teachers—now gather ourselves for what we know will be a strange, trying, and unpredictable school year ahead.

As your learning community makes its mad design dash to the start of the school year, with all your contingency plans and spreadsheets and multiple scenarios, don’t forget to keep your graduate profile, or whatever serves as your overarching set of desired learning outcomes, close at hand. Refer often to that list, and keep asking, How are we designing ways for our students to practice these skills? 

This pandemic is driving home the pre-pandemic truth that learning is not about seat time or content delivery or testing, all of which crumbled with startling quickness last spring. Learning has always been and will always be about improving one’s skills through practice, guided by coaching. Conceived as such, learning is remarkably flexible. Practice, guided by coaching, can happen at home independently, or on a video call, or in a sparsely desked classroom with children in masks. Establish practice routines for the key skills of your course. Introduce them as early as possible in the school year. Design those routines to be portable, and demonstrate that portability to your students by simulating at-home practice when you have them in your classrooms, and in-classroom practice when you have them on a video call. 

I have more to say about elevating the “practice question” in a blog I recently contributed to our friends at Future Focused Education. 

We can rise to this challenge, especially if we apply the principles of High-Quality Performance Assessment, and we can make school better than it was before.

In solidarity with educators everywhere,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

Have you had a chance to read Jal Mehta’s piece in Ed Week, “Why Equity Has Been a Conservative Force in American Education—And How That Could Change”? If you haven’t, you should.

Mehta argues that “the effort to close achievement gaps has in practice doubled down on the century-old industrial model of schooling, leaving in place all of the essential elements of its grammar: teaching as transmission, batch processing of students, conventional assessments, tracking and leveling, and all of the rest. Anything that moves away from those assumptions—like project-based learning, problem-based learning, interdisciplinary learning, authentic assessment, or constructivist pedagogy—is seen as ‘risky;’ something that is ‘OK for the privileged kids’ but somehow distracts from the real work of closing achievement gaps on state-sponsored tests.”

We at Envision Learning Partners see deeper learning not as a risk but as a moral imperative, not only because all children deserve it, but also because it’s the right way to make change. I agree with Mehta’s notion of “liberatory design,” which “assumes that teachers and students would like to develop engaging, meaningful learning experiences, and that the problem is not them but the institutional structures and culture of schools that constrains them.” I am fortunate to witness proof of this regularly in my work when, for example, I see the excitement among students and teachers who have designed and implemented a portfolio-defense system.

The teachers and leaders who reach out to partner with ELP have drawn similar conclusions about deeper learning. We are proud to serve their schools and districts, and we are always inspired by their courage to do this work.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

As you work furiously and heroically to serve your students through the COVID-19 crisis, ELP offers this advice: Don’t forget about your graduate profile. Now’s the time to lean into it.

It doesn’t matter whether your performance assessment system is well established or just getting off the ground, whether you’re currently reaching your students through Zoom or printed worksheet packets. If your learning community has a graduate profile or similar set of learner outcomes, you should use that language to remind your students of their assets and to challenge them to grow. Most graduate profiles were designed to focus us on the skills students need to navigate a fast-changing world with an unpredictable future. Now we get to put them to the test.

Many graduate or learner profiles, for example, target a competency that has to do with being a “self-directed learner.” Let’s admit that it’s a concept more aspirational than operational. In most of our highly-structured learning environments, young people have very little opportunity to practice being self-directed. Guess what? Now they need it. And we need to teach it. So invoke the skill, express high expectations for students to develop the skill during this time, give them ideas for how to practice and demonstrate it, structure opportunities for them to reflect on it, and challenge them to document evidence of their growth. This goes for any skill that’s on your graduate profile.

Stay tuned. In coming weeks, ELP will continue to share suggestions for ways to leverage or advance the elements of your performance assessment system: the use of portfolios, running defenses of learning virtually, building a culture of revision and reflection. There are enormous opportunities in this crisis for students to practice and be assessed on the skills we say are important.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

The Practice Question

Across education, I see the development of a healthy habit, and the performance assessment movement deserves plenty of credit for it. Educators everywhere, when considering a desired learning outcome, are reflexively asking, “How would we measure that?”

This is good. Asking the measurement question holds us accountable to our goals; answering it points us to actions.

But there’s another question that is just as focusing, should be just as reflexive, and would not hurt to come first: “How will our students practice that skill?”

Answer the practice question, and the measurement answer comes easily. It’s not so easy the other way around.

As a young teacher, I too often measured things that my students didn’t get to practice. I whipped out a public speaking rubric when students presented at the front of the room. I assessed them on their volume and eye contact. But we hadn’t practiced those skills in class.

Collaboration shows up on most graduate profiles. How will our students practice that skill? Answer it honestly. Assigning some group work is not the same thing as practicing collaboration.

Another grad profile meme—critical thinking—is not any kind of thinking. It’s grappling with “How might I be wrong?” How do students practice that skill? If a student has gone through a school year without consciously changing her mind on anything, then I doubt she has really practiced critical thinking.

I applaud what I see announced on graduate profiles all over the country—really important skills that schools can help kids get better at: inquiry, citizenship, creativity, persistence, problem solving, cultural competence, and so on. But it’s not fair to measure things that students haven’t had an opportunity to practice.

A high-quality performance assessment system knows its desired outcomes and its measurements; it also takes responsibility for scheduling practice.

Please share with us one of your favorite ways to help your students practice a key skill!

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

The “yes buts”—the common objections to performance assessment—keep dropping away.

The latest comes with the revolutionary announcement from the UC Board of Regents last week: Going forward, the SAT or ACT test is not required for admission to a UC campus. The requirement will be phased out completely by 2025.

And just like that, there goes the “yes but the SAT” counterargument to performance assessment system building. An institutional practice that had seemed entrenched is now revealed by the pandemic to be fragile.

We can add the SAT to a growing list that includes “Yes but instructional minutes,” “Yes but the end-of-year standardized tests,” and “Yes but the course grade.”

Meanwhile, the concept of a defense of learning has proven resilient in this crisis. ELP is proud to partner with the Learning Policy Institute and the Linked Learning Alliance to launch the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series, which in coming weeks presents multiple opportunities to observe students’ virtual defenses of learning and engage in conversations with the inspiring students and educators who have remained committed to performance assessment despite school closures. (For those of you wondering about ELP’s long running practice of Defense Design Studios, this series is where we are putting that energy this year.)

Watch this web page closely for upcoming dates associated with the “Defending Learning at a Distance” series. There are some events happening later this week. And more will be added as plans get solidified. Students and schools are moving fast. Don’t take it from us: Watch Envision student Dani Martin vlog about preparing for her virtual defense.   I can’t wait to witness what students have to say about their learning in the next couple weeks, and to discuss the implications of this with all of you in the months to come.

Stay safe,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

Here at Envision Learning Partners, we believe that every student deserves to learn within a high-quality performance assessment system. That means every student goes to a school where:

  • targeted skills are announced (often in the form a graduate profile),
  • rubrics are widely shared and regularly used,
  • teachers are aligned on the quality of assignments and student work,
  • students can explain what they are doing and how they are growing,
  • and high expectations are not random or tracked; they are held for every student who attends that school.

If a school does not have these conditions in place, or isn’t actively working toward them, then I hesitate to call it a good school, no matter how high its test scores, shiny its hallways, or champion-like its teachers.

We in the performance assessment movement must clamor for focus on the quality of our students’ work—not proxies for their work, like test scores or classroom observations, but the work itself. How are you focusing on and highlighting your students’ work? Drop us a line to let us know!

I invite you to read more of my thoughts on the subject in “What Is a Good School?,” a short piece I wrote for EdWeek’s Learning Deeply blog.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

I am excited about the upcoming Assessment for Learning Conference and encourage everyone in the performance assessment movement to join us in San Diego this February (11–13th).

For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. Having learned much from being part of this community, ELP has been hungry to see it grow. So we’re thrilled that the Assessment for Learning Project is stepping up to host its first-ever conference. The event will be populated with some of the most innovative, thoughtful, equity-minded, and visionary educators and system leaders when it comes to assessment.

ELP is proud to be a co-designer of the conference, and it’s shaping up to be a cutting-edge learning experience for attendees, who will be challenged to apply innovative assessment principles to their own 3-day learning journey. This is a conference designed for practicing, not preaching.

There are so many educators around the country who are doing incredible work to transform assessment, and this conference is a chance for us to learn with each other and build on the momentum to create an Assessment FOR Learning movement. I hope you will join us!

For more info and to register, go to www.assessmentforlearningconference.org.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

A high school principal recently lamented to me that many of his students’ grades are cratering during this time of distance learning. Much of the problem, he observes, is coming from classes whose grades are calculated using points.

Work is assigned, work is not received, and the work gets a zero in the grade book. After that, it’s out of the teacher’s hands. Simple math takes over. Average up the points. Out spits the failing grade.

Keeping our students engaged when we can’t serve them in person has, understandably, proven a challenge. Around the country, teachers are Zooming real hard and feeling disappointed by what they are getting back from students in return. But that problem is compounded by points-based grading systems, which the pandemic has exposed as a pervasive practice in our schools.

Where I see a course that organizes itself around points and percentages, I usually find a learning environment in which the teacher and the students do not share clear answers to simple questions of purpose: What are our learning goals? What are the skills we are focused on improving? What are the ways that students can demonstrate their progress?

Two principles of ELP’s High-Quality Performance Assessment (HQPA) framework are particularly germane here: 1) tight on criteria for success and 2) open to different learner approaches. In a course that is rooted in HQPA, students can describe what success looks like with words, not numbers. And the teacher can point out different paths to success. In such a course, there is no reason why a student cannot, in a single, convincing performance of the targeted skills, redeem a whole semester’s worth of struggle.

If there’s one educational practice that I wish this pandemic would eradicate, it is the use of points for calculating course grades. Its disappearance would be a major advance toward an educational system where assessment is for learning, not for sorting.

With respect and gratitude for the work of educators everywhere.

Sometimes it’s important, in our jargon-loving profession, to put things as plainly we can. That’s certainly true for a concept such as performance assessment.

A word that comes in handy is the word challenge. I use it for two key questions:

The first is, How are we challenging our students?

Schools and districts that are consciously building a performance assessment system tend to have crisp answers to that question: “We challenge our students to do a year-long research project.” “Our 3rd graders plan and facilitate their own conferences.” “11th graders must design and implement a statistical analysis with help from an outside expert.” “Our kids have to defend their learning every two years.”

The second question is then, How are we challenging ourselves and our system to prepare our students for their challenges?

Again, I am encouraged by crisp answers: “We look at student work and calibrate on our rubrics once per month.” “Our grade level teams meet in the summer to design two multi-disciplinary projects per year.” “The science department will be using a Next-Gen-aligned rubric for assessing inquiry projects next year.” “We’re investing in PD so that our teachers can teach public speaking across the curriculum.”

Try it. As you build your performance assessment system, keep asking, “How are we challenging our students?” and “How are we challenging ourselves?” Tighten up your answers. Then live them.

Sincerely,

Justin Wells, ELP Executive Director

One widespread way that schools have adapted to the pandemic, particularly at the secondary level, is a dramatic restructuring of the “bell schedule.” In the virtual and hybrid contexts we’re now operating in, many students are taking, and teachers are teaching, fewer classes at one time, typically made possible by shortening the length of courses or chunking them into alternating modules (which is what we are doing here at Envision Schools).

The challenges are obvious: These new schedules are born of compromise. They are harder to manage for some disciplines than others. Abrupt change is exhausting. But they do present an opportunity for advancing a key element of your performance assessment system—the culture of reflection and revision among teachers.

In a functioning performance assessment system, students’ work (their response to assignments) informs teachers’ work (their design of assignments) in a process that is collaborative and continual. With courses on faster cycles, there are more opportunities to iterate. A semester-long course, if offered twice during the year, doubles the pace of iteration.

Let’s acknowledge that making time for collaborative revision of courses is not easy. Right now, the brute logistics of delivering instruction in the midst of a pandemic are monopolizing our energies. But as we get deeper into the fall, ELP urges educators to dedicate some of your precious PD time, in whatever form it comes, to sharing assessments and analyzing student work, building your system’s muscles for reflection and revision. 

Shorter courses demand even crisper answers to the questions that never go away: What do students need to learn, and how will we know they have learned it?

When teachers do have opportunities to share their work with each other, we encourage you to use ELP’s principles of High Quality Performance Assessment (HQPA) as a common language for exchanging feedback. We offer both a set of look-fors and single-point rubrics for each of the five principles. Don’t hesitate to reach out to us with questions on how to use these tools in your learning community.

with respect and gratitude for the work of educators everywhere.

This is an interactive hands-on workshop where participants will prototype a high quality performance assessment (HQPA) aligned to deeper learning competencies. Through learning stations, participants will explore the what and why of performance assessments and use quality criteria tools to analyze for rigor, learner agency, and authenticity. Participants will then prototype their ideal HQPA and brainstorm the potential implications on their school structures and pedagogies. The design experience will culminate with participants sharing their performance assessment tasks, identifying next first steps, and reflecting on their own learning and leadership.

Join us to…

  • explore HQPA in relation to the design of a single task/challenge
  • prototype or refine a task/challenge that aligns to HQPA and is designed so our most marginalized students can thrive

Learn more about the full event here

Abby in 2010

I am writing to share the news that December 30th marked my final day at Envision Learning Partners.  It is impossible to put into words the depth of gratitude and appreciation I have for Envision as an organization, and for all of the amazing humans whom I have met over the past fifteen years(!!!!) – inside and outside of the org.  Having spent the last decade and a half learning how to be an educator committed to deeper learning, and learning how to engage in transformative systems change work, there is no way that I can capture the role that Envision has played in my professional and personal evolution.  

What did you most enjoy about being a coach with ELP?

I had no idea the profound impact that ELP would have on my life when I said yes to the opportunity to help found the organization and dream up what we wanted to do and be back in 2010.  As I look back now, over a decade later, it is… of course… the people who have taught me the most, and whom I hold in my heart as I make my way through the world.  Courageous and visionary school leaders from Hawaii to Maine who have invited me in to their most sacred place – their schools.  Boundlessly passionate educators who have pushed their own practice with open hearts and open minds in order better support their most sacred people – their students.  Brilliant partners who are doing the work in organizations across the country, confronting a complex and entrenched system that we all know can and needs to be better. And the ELP team… oh, the humans who are ELP… I have been held, challenged, taught, supported, encouraged, questioned, and loved by these humans in the most foundational of ways.  So it feels quite impossible to describe what I have enjoyed the most about being a coach with ELP because it has been my identity for so long.  The enjoyment is just one dimension of all that ELP has added to my life.  Mostly, it has been all of you… so, thank you.

Why am I leaving and what am I doing next

It has been a deeply moving decision to say goodbye to these people and this place, and say yes to the unknown.  But I feel called to set out on a new challenge, and to see where it takes me.  As 2020 unfolded and the world was newly turned upside down because of covid, the persistent and inexcusable murders of unarmed Black men and women, forest fires raging around us, and clear threats to our democracy, I found myself heavy with so many questions of what am I doing? and what can I do?  While I don’t feel that I have any definitive answers to those questions at this point, the process has led me to some new lenses of purpose and focus.

I am excited to announce that I have started my own consulting business called Core Shifts (website coming soon).  I believe deeply in the power of performance assessment, and will continue to partner with schools and districts to support the work of building systems organized around the skills that young people need in order to go out into the world and create the lives in which they will thrive.  I am excited to continue to partner with ELP in this work so that all students can experience the power of owning their own story of learning and growth.  Simultaneously, I feel compelled to continue to confront and grapple with the ways in which my identity as a white woman within education has contributed, and still contributes to the oppression of marginalized students and adults.  I am committed to doing the ongoing mirror work myself so that I can better explicitly name, analyze, and be an effective co-conspirator in working to reduce and ultimately dismantle the hold that white supremacy culture has on public education.  (One way I have been practicing this internal work is through the co-design and co-facilitation of an anti-racist learning experience for white folks in affinity space with another former Envisioner.  It is called What is at Your Core and you can learn more about that on the website.  Our next course starts this month, if you know of anyone who might be interested). 

It is at the explicit intersection of system redesign and anti-racist work that I hope to build Core Shifts.  I have a lot to learn, and I am ready to lean into the challenge.

There are no words to capture how much of who I am now is because of my time at Envision Education, and Envision Learning Partners.  I continue to be deeply inspired by the passion, the commitment, the vulnerability, and the care with which this organization and all of the incredible clients and partners with whom we work take on the unthinkably complex job of holding our young people at the center of all that we do… especially this year. Please know how grateful I am to have learned with you.

You can find me at abby@core-shifts.com.

Events

ELP continues to have a strong presence at conferences all over the US in 19-20:

  • EdLeader21 conference last month in Houston, Texas. Our Executive Director, Justin Wells, facilitated a breakout session (with a district team from Springfield, MO) called Portrait to Performance with Portfolios.
  • iNACOL, also last month, in Palm Springs, California. Our Deeper Learning Coach, Abby Benedetto, delivered the latest version of ELP’s Grad Profile 101 workshop.

Upcoming conferences:

  • Assessment for Learning (February 2020) in San Diego, California, mentioned in this newsletter’s ED message. For the past three years, the educators and system leaders of the Assessment for Learning Project have been designing, learning, and innovating together to reimagine what’s possible for assessment. ELP will be hosting workshops throughout the conference focused on Student Exhibitions & Defense of Learning.

Announcements

NEW ELP PARTNERS FOR 19-20

Each school year, ELP welcomes new education partners from across the country. Please join us in welcoming:

  • East Palo Alto Academy: ELP will be working with EPAA to synthesize a clear vision for their graduates and build teacher capacity to integrate projects with rigorous assessments of content standards and transferable skills.
  • Cleveland Metro Schools: ELP will be partnering with John Adams College & Career Academy to design a system of performance assessments that are aligned with their vision of a graduate and lead the graduating class of 2022 through Portfolio Defenses.
  • Davis Joint Unified School District: ELP will be prototyping “defense of learning” systems aligned to the Davis USD Graduate Profile and accelerating the implementation of these systems among a cohort of piloting schools in the district.
  • Fairfax County Public Schools: ELP will be assisting this innovative district with their student presentations of learning, providing feedback and an outside perspective.
  • Purdue Polytechnic High School: ELP will build on the strengths at Purdue to align a cohesive performance assessment system, culminating in a capstone portfolio and defense.
  • IL State Board of Ed: ELP worked with ISBE to identify and implement a project around needed resources, guidance, and support for Illinois to best understand how to provide competency-based education, performance-based assessment, and establish a shared culture of innovation to promote equity for all students. (This represents an opportunity for Illinois-based school districts, so please reach out to learn more.)

GATES FOUNDATION PROFESSIONAL LEARNING PARTNERSHIP GRANT

We are delighted to share that ConnectED and Envision Learning Partners are partnering with the San Diego Unified School District to enhance the integrated sequence of the Illustrative Mathematics high school curriculum. This work is funded by a grant from the Gates Foundation. In collaboration with our partners, we will leverage existing curriculum-embedded instructional resources and parent engagement approaches, elevating strategies that close achievement gaps for English Learners.

The Assessment for Learning Conference 2021

ELP is pleased to partner again with the Center for Innovation in Education and Next Generation Learning Challenges on the 2021 Assessment for Learning Conference!

The guiding question for AFL 2021 is: How will the assessment for learning movement lead us through the crises of the moment to a more just, equitable and student-centered future of learning?

AFL 2021 blurs the line between conference and community of practice. Think of it as a series of missions to escape the gravitational pull of our assumptions and to-do lists, so that we can find space for sharing, reflecting, connecting and imagining.

Get a head start on AFL 2021 right now! Join one of the free 75-minute virtual sessions to cut through the space junk, surface challenges and opportunities, share resources, and help us set the priorities for AFL 2021!

Learn more and register here.

The National Geographic Society

ELP had the pleasure of leading the National Geographic Society and members of their global community through a Design Sprint. In facilitating a Liberatory Design Process, the team was able to develop a set of design principles that will be the foundation for future work and a lens with which to understand and refine past work.

DLLF: Where are they now?

We’re highlighting some of the DLLF alumni who are making moves- achieving goals, serving their communities, and impacting the future of education. Click here to read more about some of their achievements.

ELP has worked with 58 educational leaders from all over the United States since 2016 and we’re excited to open applications for our fifth cohort early next year!

Join us TOMORROW in the ELP Lounge!

The ELP Lounge will offer time to share stories, thought partnership with peers, or just the chance to throw up your hands and say, am I the only one experiencing this??? Plan to stop in and slow down to connect, share, learn, & heal. We can’t wait to see you.

Thursday, November 18th, 4:00-5:00pm PT (7:00-8:00pm ET)

Click here to grab your free ticket!

‍
Deeper Learning Conference 2022

‍Share space with change-makers like you who are in search of a collective experience to highlight current triumphs and challenges, leverage student voice, and move from aspiration to action.Happening in-person and virtually, March 29th-31st, 2021. Get your tickets here.

‍More details about ELP’s sessions to come!

Envision Learning Partners is delighted and honored to introduce Alliance College-Ready Public Schools. ELP and Alliance kicked off our partnership in the 2018-19 school year. In our first year we worked together to deeply engage around building Alliance’s Graduate Profile (shown below). In 2019-20, we have been engaged with the Alliance team to develop a vertical articulation of the graduate profile.

Fifteen years ago a group of Los Angeles educators, civil rights activists, and community leaders believed in great public schools. They believed all kids could learn, regardless of zip code or background. They believed they could make a difference––and they did. Together, they founded Alliance College-Ready Public Schools to challenge the status quo for public education.

Today, 95% of Alliance seniors graduate high school and are accepted to college; 73% to a four-year college or university. In comparison, when Alliance opened its first public charter school in 2004 at the corner of Western and Martin Luther King Boulevard, the high school graduation rate in Los Angeles was 49%––many Los Angeles high schools were known as drop-out factories.

Eva Luc is the Director of Strategic Initiatives and College Success at Alliance and has shared her thoughts on our work together below.

Alliance Design Team working at a Vertical Alignment Workshop

What have you learnt during this process?

It’s critical to authentically engage the communities we serve and the staff on the ground, because they are ultimately the ones impacted by and carrying out the work, and they deserve to be front and center in the process. Otherwise, you risk creating for and not with folks. We are proud that school leaders, teachers, counselors, parent specialists, families, and scholars  past and present co-created the Alliance Graduate Profile, and are also part of the vertical articulation and design teams.

Based on our scholars’ experiences, research and best practices, we know that academic strength is just part of what makes a successful Alliance graduate in whatever their chosen path beyond high school might be. The Graduate Profile provides a north star of the full set of skills (beyond just the academics) that we, as a network, should be focusing on. It allows us to have a cohesive vision of scholar success that we work towards collectively.

Is there one story you can share that illustrates how this work is benefitting your school and your students?

So far, the Graduate Profile has already impacted Alliance scholars in a positive way. Our Graduate Profile emphasized social and emotional learning so much so that Alliance created a new team – Scholar, Family and Community Services – this year to develop a framework for Social Emotional Learning and align resources to support that framework.

Read more about our partnership with Alliance in our January Guest Blog, written by Deeper Learning Coach, Morgan Vien.